Building Resiliency Seen as Economic Growth

The debate motion for the Asian Forum on Corporate Social Responsibility 2014 held recently in Manila, Philippines is “Building resilient communities is mainly about economic growth.” Our Asia 21 leaders Arnel Casanova and Vivian Claire Liew spoke for the Proposition, before an audience of 500+ corporate and social leaders, though with a larger segment from NGOs.

Their stand was that creating or developing a high degree of adaptive capacity, and thus the ability to bounce back from natural or man-made disruptions, in groups of people with shared identities and destinies, is for the most part, enabled by GDP growth and its fruits; financial resources and the formation of human capital, accruing directly or indirectly from social investments in education, nutrition, healthcare, infrastructure in communications, transport and other logistics. Economic growth allows us to pay the worker his due, thus enabling the recruitment of competent people, the bedrock of all effective and high-performing organizations. This facilitates capacity building and good governance, and thus the development of a good system to anticipate, to prepare and to manage. The converse – the lack of economic growth leads to the disenfranchisement of youth, who lack resources to build their lives and families. They thus lack hope and grasp at straws, giving extremists an opening, which imposes a greater burden on the rest of society.

Vivian thus contended that “Economic growth is the water of life that nurtures resilient communities.” This can be the high GDP growth of 6-7% enjoyed by the Philippines, or the lower GDP growth of Japan – 1.4% and 1.5% in 2012, and 2013 respectively, and 1.6% this year, per IMF projections. Countries with wise leadership, who have probably received excellent education and training – enabled by economic growth, will be able to discern and implement the right economic strategies that make their particular economy more sustainable.

Arnel noted that “Poverty imprisons the minds of the poor” and that “The lack of resources strips you of human dignity”. Scarcity of resources leads to conflict; he’d seen an entire village of 300 people burned down because of a land dispute. He further supported the motion by sharing on how a lack of technology affected the Ondoy disaster efforts vs the Doppler radar system that helped evacuation thereafter and which is funded by economic growth.

The opposition comprising of Dr. Kristine Gebbie from the Torrens Resilience Institute in Australia and Clinton’s public health czar in 2003-4, and Dr. Thitinan Pongsudhirak, Director of Chulalongkorn’s Institute of Security and International Studies, noted that economic growth was overrated and can erode resilience, and that resilience was about the human spirit, planning, connectedness and connectivity, plus a host of other factors. “Greed is good” Dr. Thitinan mockingly said, continuing a subtle subtext from Kristine’s opening counter. That set the stage for an emotional response from the audience where a majority noted that resilience was not all about economic growth, and that in economically strong countries, there were fewer trials and tribulations.

Debate duties aside, Vivian noted that both she and Arnel’s individual gut reactions on hearing the debate motion was to lean towards the opposition. Building resilient communities involves many key factors of which economic resources is one. But as noted in her speech, without economic growth, building resilient communities is not possible in the long run.

Related Content

Asia 21 Young Leaders engage in a dialogue on Shaping Tomorrow’s Leaders and Rockstars: Is Our Education System Ready'
A conversation with Asia 21 Young Leaders featuring Ibba Bernardo, Scot Frank, and Rommel Juan
Deepak Ravindran, founder of Innoz Technologies shares why he is giving away the source code for his SMS search engine.
The Philippine Alumni convened at the 2nd Asia 21 Philippines Reunion and commit to public work
Asia 21 Young Leaders Debate for Building Resiliency Seen as Economic Growth
For bringing news, information and entertainment to a barren landscape
For eye-opening films that give voice to the voiceless
Our India-Pakistan Asia 21 Leaders ‘Defeating the Stereotypes’
In the Philippines, indigenous culture can help bring people together.
The Asia 21 Young Leaders Class of 2013 went to Bhutan for a public service project.
As Afghanistan reels from a devastating natural disaster, members of Asia Society's Afghanistan 21 Young Leaders Initiative are actively coordinating relief efforts.
Asia 21 Young Leader Arnel Casanova speaks about country's cities of tomorrrow
Afghanistan's first-ever presidential debate was televised by Tolo News, which is headed by two executives with Asia Society ties.
Asia 21 Young Leaders Youth Summit in Jalalabad
Upholding the Asia 21 mantra of public service, Asia 21 Young Leader Rick Pal (US), founder of Ek Disha, has been turning his passion to action by collaborating with his fellow Asia 21 young leaders in the Philippines, India, and Pakistan.
Asia Society Young Leaders Youth Summit in Herat
Technology and creativity for dignity, rights and welfare of marginalized groups.
Empowerment of the young and indigenous peoples in the Philippines.