Navigating the Belt and Road Initiative
Recommendations to ensure beneficial and sustainable BRI outcomes
Paula Bronstein/Getty Images
Explore the Recommendations for the Belt and Road Initiative
Click on a recommendation to learn more below
Recommendation 12
BRI Database
Develop a searchable, comprehensive, up-to-date, English-language BRI project database
Collaborative
Open
How Would it Work?
Chinese Government
- Catalog all completed, ongoing, and prospective BRI projects in one database, with the maximum possible information on project financing, design, execution, parties involved, project terms, etc.
- The database should be not only in Chinese but also in English and other languages.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Clarify the Belt and Road Initiative
- The existing BRI Portal contains minimal information.
- Address confusion over what projects are considered part of the BRI.
Invite International Participation
- Enhance project transparency and opportunities for public understanding, engagement, and participation.
- Improve access to BRI project opportunities for international financers and vendors, thereby raising project quality and sustainability.
- Enable analysis and research on the BRI, providing useful information to countries seeking to participate.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- The "Belt and Road Ecological and Environmental Plan" calls for "a big data service platform" which will "provide comprehensive information support," "strengthen information sharing," and "stimulate cooperation."
- The NDRC and Ministry of Finance maintain open project databases for domestic and overseas investments, as well as PPP projects.
- The AIIB has a comprehensive database of proposed and approved projects, which contains salient information regarding the projects.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The ADB maintains a project database that provides access to key documents on projects financed by the bank.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 1
Project Preparation Process
Require and conduct a rigorous, comprehensive, and transparent project preparation process
Green
Clean
Affordable
How Would it Work?
Chinese Government, Project Developers, and Contracted Companies
- Prior to project approval, Chinese authorities should require that a rigorous and transparent project preparation process be undertaken.
- Conduct risk and life cycle assessments for new materials, processes, and methods.
- Cancel or substantially change projects found to be financially or otherwise nonviable.
- Design project based on careful assessments.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Improve Project Oversight
- Many developing countries lack the resources or capacity to conduct appropriate viability analysis.
- Minimize the risk of project failure through thorough pre-project viability analysis and due diligence.
- Provide project financers and developers with a clearer understanding of the local political, social, environmental, and economic context.
Invite International Participation
- Nonviable projects do not attract private and international investment and can saddle host governments with unsustainable debt.
Build Support for the BRI
- Reduce the likelihood of debt-for-equity swaps and environmental or social damage, which can result in resentment toward China and the BRI.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- The China Banking Regulatory Commission's (CBRC's) “Standardization of Banking Services Enterprises to 'Go Out' and Strengthen the Guidance of Control and Risk Prevention" states that financial institutions should conduct an in-depth and independent assessment of the environmental, legal, and social risks in evaluating a project's feasibility.
- The China International Contractors Association's (CHINCA's) "Guidelines of Sustainable Infrastructure for Chinese International Contractors” outline what should be included in a project feasibility report.
- The National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) and Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development's "Guiding Opinions on Boosting Development of Whole-Process Engineering Consulting Services" emphasize the importance of conducting comprehensive project feasibility studies.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The G20 "Principles for the Infrastructure Project Preparation Phase" and Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation's "Guidebook on Quality Infrastructure Development and Investment" delineate critical issues to address within each step of the project preparation process.
- The World Bank's "A Diagnostic Framework for Assessing Public Investment Management" outlines the essential features and necessary steps prior to embarking on the construction phase of an infrastructure project with public investment.
- The Asian Development Bank (ADB) provides multiple guidelines on how to conduct project preparation assessments.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 2
Project Preparation Fund
Establish a BRI project preparation fund
Affordable
Open
How Would it Work?
Chinese Government
- Establish a BRI PPF fund.
- Award grants as needed to support states considering BRI projects to fund analysis of needs, viability, and factors relevant to decision-making and project design.
- PPF advisory contracts should be open to international firms and competitively bid on.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Host Country Capacity
- Host countries may lack the capacity, resources, or expertise necessary to evaluate projects.
- Create better alignment with host countries' needs.
- Bolster developers and host countries capacity to identify and navigate potential issues.
Attract Private Capital
- Projects that undergo a comprehensive assessment have greater viability and credibility on the international market and facilitate international public and private participation.
- Rigorous assessment during the pre-project stage reduces the risk of failure and lowers project costs.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- The "Guiding Principles on Financing the Development of the Belt and Road" state that China will use public funds for the planning and construction of major projects.
- The Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) established a PPF in 2016.
- The Ministry of Finance and the New Development Bank signed a PPF agreement in 2017.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The World Bank, European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD), and ADB have prepared or established project preparation facilities.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 3
Standardized Project Contracts
Develop a BRI FIDIC-based “standard contract” with required, recommended, and optional provisions
Clean
Affordable
Open
How Would it Work?
Chinese Government
- Use International Federation of Consulting Engineers (FIDIC) standard contracts as a template for developing a standard contract for BRI with mandatory and optional provisions.
- Make BRI standard contracts publicly available.
- Conduct oversight to ensure contracts meet FIDIC standards.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Project Quality
- The lack of consistency between contracts yields inconsistent approaches and outcomes.
- Reduce risk of delays and resulting costs.
- Establish standard dispute resolution procedure mitigating potential delays and costs.
- Improve project oversight through the role of the engineering consultants.
Increase Multilateral Support
- Improve credibility of BRI by adhering to internationally-recognized standards.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- China's Ministry of Construction, State Industrial and Commercial Administration Bureau, and NDRC use standard contracts in domestic tendering.
- China's State Council adopted regulations requiring disclosure of major construction and other related information domestically.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The World Bank, EBRD, and ADB all use FIDIC standard infrastructure development contracts.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 4
Blended Financing for PPPs
Use blended finance to ensure that BRI projects are commercially viable and can attract international private and public financing (i.e., PPPs)
Affordable
Open
How Would it Work?
Chinese Government and Development Banks and Financing Institutions
- Use blended financing instruments, including investment grants, viability gap funding, technical assistance, loan guarantees, and publicly disclosed official development assistance as appropriate for high-priority projects that are not financially viable or affordable but justified in development or economic terms.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Reputation and Sustainability
- Diminish concerns that China is purposefully "debt trapping" less developed nations through the BRI.
- Expand the pool of development funds available for financing ambitious infrastructure projects.
- Expand relationships and facilitate new commercial opportunities between international and Chinese companies.
Reduce Risks
- Huge amounts of public money are spent on BRI projects, many of which are not commercially viable.
- Chinese developers can pursue unprofitable projects due to their easy access to government funds.
- Commercial banks and investors will apply rigorous standards to ensure fiscal viability of the project and commercial returns.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- At the Second Belt and Road Forum, Xi Jinping called for multilateral development bank financing in BRI projects.
- The "Guiding Principles on Financing the Development of the Belt and Road" state that policy financial institutions and export credit agencies of the countries involved should continue to offer financial support for the BRI and play a role in financing promotion and risk sharing.
- The memorandum of understanding (MOU) between the NDRC and the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe on promoting the PPP model for the BRI outlines how to establish a sound legal, regulatory, and governance framework for PPP projects and how to attract investment.
- The Ministry of Finance's 2019 "Guidance Note on Setting Standards for PPP Projects and Encouraging Private and Foreign Participation" provides standards for PPP projects and improving information disclosure through a national PPP information platform.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The World Bank, ADB, EBRD, and Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) encourage PPP for infrastructure projects and have guidelines and frameworks on how to do so.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 5
Transparent Procurement
Ensure an open and transparent project procurement process
Clean
Affordable
Open
How Would it Work?
Project Developers
- All companies, including Chinese state-owned enterprises, submit their bids for contracts through an established e-procurement system.
- Ensure contracts are awarded on a best value for money and quality basis.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Increase Project Efficiency and Quality
- Reduce procurement time, corruption, and waste through an automated system.
- Many project contracts are not competitively bid, allowing companies to be paid for services or equipment which are never delivered.
Build Support for the BRI
- Build trust among participating parties and attract international private firms and development banks.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- China has used e-procurement domestically since 2014.
- Chinabidding.com.cn, jointly created by China and the World Bank, releases procurement notices in real time.
- The Joint Communiques of the Leaders' Roundtable from the 2017 and 2019 Belt and Road Forums underscore the "importance of open, transparent, and non-discriminatory public procurement procedures."
- The AIIB's procurement policy encourages the utilization of an e-procurement system.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The OECD recommends the use of an e-procurement system as it improves transparency, efficiency, and accountability throughout the procurement process.
- The ADB's "Standard Bidding Documents and User's Guide to Procurement Works" and "E-Procurement: Guidance Note on Procurement" provide detailed instructions for bidders and the steps to develop and implement the system.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 6
Environmental and Social Impact Assessment
Conduct rigorous, transparent, community-engaged, and publicly available environmental and social impact assessments
Green
Collaborative
How Would it Work?
Project Developers
- Conduct ESIAs after project approval and prior to construction that examine environmental and social impact management; land rights; security, health, and safety; stakeholder engagement and information disclosure; and labor issues.
- Publicize ESIA conclusions in the local language and in English.
- Implement the procedures to mitigate or avoid adverse impacts during the project's life cycle.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Increase Project Quality
- ESIAs have been falsified or bypassed completely, leading to problems.
- ESIAs rarely engage stakeholders or are translated into local languages and made publicly available.
- Enforcement of environmental standards in host countries is often lax, resulting in expensive delays, local resistance, and liability issues.
- Proper ESIAs enhance transparency and investor confidence, reduce risk, and provide a comprehensive and realistic view of the challenges facing the project, as well as options for mitigation.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- China's Environmental Impact Assessment Law stipulates that before construction begins, ESIA documents must be reviewed and approved by relevant departments.
- The CBRC's “Standardization of Banking Services Enterprises to 'Go Out' and Strengthen the Guidance of Control and Risk Prevention" encourages financial institutions to conduct ESIAs in evaluating the project's feasibility.
- CBRC's "Green Credit Directive" sets out a mechanism to ensure proper environmental and social risk due diligence and the need to complete a environmental and social risk report.
- The NDRC's "Code of Conduct for Overseas Investment Operations by Private Enterprises" states that before construction, firms should undertake environmental assessments of the propose construction site.
- The AIIB has well developed guidelines on conducting an ESIA, consulting with local stakeholders, and information disclosure.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The World Bank's "Environmental and Social Framework" outlines the requirements and standards for conducting environmental and social assessments and how to undertake the assessments.
- The ADB's "Environmental Assessment Guidelines" details the procedures and requirements for undertaking an environmental impact assessment and provides a framework for conducting public consultations.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 7
Stakeholder Engagement
Require and enable stakeholder engagement throughout the project life cycle, including by establishing a local grievance mechanism
Green
Collaborative
Clean
How Would it Work?
Project Developers and Contracted Companies
- Establish a local-language grievance mechanism to answer questions and handle complaints in coordination with local processes.
- Publicize the mechanism in the local language and through a website and include information on how to register complaints/related procedures.
- The mechanism should be confidential and be based on a nonretaliation principle.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Communication and Early Warning
- Chinese developers are currently not funded, staffed, or trained to deal with civil society, resulting in social issues.
- Provide project developers with an early warning system to better detect emerging problems and useful contacts to mitigate issues.
Build Support for the BRI
- Reduce tensions between local communities and Chinese developers, thereby reducing the likelihood of protests causing project delay or cancellation.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- China's domestic Law on Labor Dispute Mediation and Arbitration calls for local governments to establish mechanisms to jointly resolve issues with union and enterprise representatives.
- CHINCA's "Guide to Social Responsibility for Chinese International Contractors" states that companies must establish negotiation and communication mechanisms to support the participation of employees and respond to complaints and expectations.
- The AIIB established its Project-Affected People's Mechanism and Grievance Redress Mechanism in 2018.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The World Bank's "A Guide to Designing and Implementing Grievance Mechanisms for Development Projects" and "How-To Note: Feedback Matters: Designing Effective Grievance Redress Mechanisms for Bank Financed Projects" provide procedures on how to design and implement a grievance mechanism, best practices, and how to operate the mechanism.
- The ADB's "Building Capacity for Grievance Redress Mechanism" and "Accountability Mechanism Policy" provide comprehensive guidelines on how to establish and operate a grievance and complaint handling mechanism.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 8
Protect Labor Rights
Better regulate the use of Chinese workers in overseas projects
Collaborative
How Would it Work?
Project Developers
- Assess and document the need for and size of the imported workforce.
- Analyze the impact of labor influx on the local community and develop plans to mitigate adverse consequences.
- Conduct stakeholder consultation, exhaust options for locally sourced labor, and provide for local training.
- Establish a complaint handling mechanism to ensure that workers' rights are upheld.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Mitigate Local Resentment
- Foreign labor influx can cause local resentment, environmental damage, and social ills.
- Ensure benefits for the local economy and communities.
Protect Labor Rights
- Grievance mechanisms can provide an early warning system of potential problems.
- Prevent labor abuses and resulting protests or project disruptions.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- The Ministry of Construction and Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security's 2004 joint measures recognize the principle of holding the project developer ultimately responsible for wage payments.
- The CBRC's "Standardization of Banking Services Enterprises to 'Go Out' and Strengthen the Guidance of Control and Risk Prevention" explicitly states that companies should preserve the rights of the local population and workers, respect local culture, and establish a grievance mechanism.
- CHINCA has a Dispatched Labour Service Personnel Complaint Center to address worker complaints and protect overseas workers.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The World Bank's "Managing the Risks of Adverse Impacts on Communities From Temporary Project Induced Labor Influx" provides guidance on managing the adverse impacts from labor influxes and delineates the responsibilities for ensuring workers' rights.
- · The United Nations and International Labour Organization have a series of conventions, policies, and guidelines that outline practices to protect the rights of migrant workers.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 9
Local Materials, Labor, and Businesses
Expand and improve the use of local labor and businesses, including through “up-skilling” programs
Collaborative
How Would it Work?
Project Developers and Contracted Companies
- Allow adequate lead time for training to create a pool of qualified local labor.
- Encourage the use of local materials in project procurement processes.
- Encourage partnerships with local business in project tendering/procurement.
- Create and/or support technical and management training programs for local workers in construction and for eventual transition to local operation in build-operate-transfer projects.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Integrate Into Host Country
- Increase buy-in for projects to reduce risks and enhance long-term sustainability.
- Reliance on Chinese labor reduces project benefits and generates social tensions for and in project host countries.
- Fostering relevant skills transfer to local workers improves longer-term project operations.
Support Local Economy
- The import of Chinese material, products, and labor does not promote the economic development of the host country.
- Enhance cooperation between Chinese and local businesses.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- The NDRC's "Code of Conduct for Overseas Investments of Private Enterprises" calls for private enterprises engaged in overseas activities to actively create employment opportunities for locals.
- CHINCA's "Guide to Social Responsibility for Chinese International Contractors" states that developers and firms should prioritize the procurement of local products and services to advance local operations and cultivate local employees.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The ADB's "Domestic Preference: Guidance Note on Procurement" provides comprehensive guidelines on how to approach incorporating and using local goods and services in procurement.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 10
Clean BRI
Adopt “Clean BRI” anticorruption/antibribery oversight, enforcement, and reporting mechanisms
Clean
How Would it Work?
Chinese Government
- Adopt a "Clean BRI" platform and make anticorruption a cornerstone of the BRI through legal and policy documents, contracts and MOUs, and establish whistle-blower and enforcement mechanisms.
State-Owned Enterprises, Development Banks, and Contracted Companies
- Formulate, implement, and report on clearly defined international anticorruption conventions and industry best practices.
- Obtain anticorruption certification from a reputable body to qualify for BRI projects.
- Train staff to address and mitigate corruption.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Reputation
- Evidence and accusations of large-scale corruption and bribery hurt the reputation of both China and the BRI brand.
- Safeguarding against corruption facilitates the participation of international lenders and contractors.
Financial Incentives
- Corruption lowers project efficiency and raises project costs.
- Mitigate fiscal risk by ensuring public funds are allocated in a transparent and market-based manner.
Enhance Project Quality
- Ensure that contracts are awarded on a value-for-money and quality basis.
- Corruption reduces the sustainability of infrastructure projects.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- At the Second Belt and Road Forum, Xi Jinping called for those involved in the BRI to "fight corruption together with zero tolerance" and established the Beijing Initiative for the Clean Silk Road.
- The NDRC's 2017 "Code of Conduct for Overseas Investment Operations by Private Enterprises" and 2018 "Guidelines on Enterprise Compliance Management of Overseas Operations" explicitly call for Chinese enterprises to comply with anticorruption, antibribery, and anti-money laundering requirements.
- The State-Owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission of the State Council (SASAC) and the World Bank jointly held a "Training Workshop on Corporate Compliance for Chinese Enterprises Operating in Belt and Road Countries" in January 2018.
- The AIIB's Policy on Prohibited Practices establishes reporting, whistle-blower protection, suspension, and debarment mechanisms to address fraud and corruption.
International Best Practices and Standards
International Standards
- The United Nations Convention Against Corruption outlines anticorruption regulations and provides preventative and enforcement mechanisms.
- The OCED's "Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions" provides guidance on handling and mitigating corruption.
- The ADB's "Integrity Principles and Guidelines 2015" detail mechanisms, offices, and policies to combat corruption.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
Recommendation 11
BRI Units
Create BRI units in Chinese embassies in project countries
Collaborative
Clean
How Would it Work?
Chinese Government and Chinese Embassies in Project Host Countries
- Form units composed of relevant Chinese agencies to conduct BRI oversight, coordination, etc.
Newly Established BRI Units
- Monitor activities of Chinese developers, contractors, and personnel.
- Serve as a public and business point of contact regarding BRI projects to promote transparency.
- Liaise with and advise Chinese developers, ensure adherence to local laws, and facilitate coordination with host governments and civil society organizations.
- Help ensure functioning of dispute resolution mechanisms and compensation processes.
- Participate in regular Donor Assistance Group meetings with other embassies and host governments.
What Would It Accomplish or Prevent?
Communication and Local Knowledge
- Meeting with other donor embassies and host governments facilitates coordination and transparency.
- Chinese embassies currently have little visibility into BRI projects, limiting opportunities for project oversight.
- Embassies' local-language capabilities and political/social knowledge can help developers prevent problems and avoid mistakes.
China's Development Practices
Chinese Precedent
- The NDRC's "Code of Conduct for Overseas Investment Operations by Private Enterprises" encourages the creation of communication channels between local operations and Chinese embassies and consulates.
- SASAC's "Guiding Opinions on Strengthening Prevention and Control of Overseas Integrity Risks of Central Enterprises" emphasize the need to strengthen supervision and management of overseas personnel, improve coordination between supervision departments, and establish a unit to prevent and manage overseas integrity risks.
Watch the video to learn more about this recommendation:
About the Project
This project is led by ASPI Vice President for International Security and Diplomacy Daniel Russel, with support from ASPI Senior Program Officer Blake Berger. The project and its resulting report benefitted from significant advisement from a global taskforce of experts in the infrastructure finance, development, labor, environmental, and other sectors. The report’s pre-publication findings and recommendations were socialized with officials in China and Southeast Asia ahead of China’s April 2019 Belt and Road Forum.
Supporters
Related Commentary
-
Daniel Russel writes that adjustments to China's BRI projects will bring benefits.
-
If China's leaders are serious about reform, there are several things they can do to cut down on corruption, waste, and local anger.
-
Daniel Russel joins ChinaFile to discuss the latest on China's Belt and Road Initiative after the 2019 Belt and Road Forum.
-
Blake Berger on how China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and Japan’s Partnership for Quality Infrastructure (PQI) affect the integration in ASEAN today.
-
The need for early engagement of local stakeholders: Asia Society Policy Institute Vice President Daniel Russel on the Belt and Road Initiative in Southeast Asia
Report Launch Event
-
20 Jun 20198:30 - 10 a.m.Join us for a conversation with Daniel Russel and others on the BRI and what can be done to ensure that BRI projects are mutually beneficial and sustainable.
Press Release
-
It identifies five main themes in its findings and recommendations.