What Should the Trump Administration Do in Asia? 11 Experts Weigh In | Asia Society Skip to main content
  • Arts
    • Asia Society Museum
      • Visit
      • Exhibitions
      • Programs
      • Learn
      • Support
    • Arts & Museum Summit
    • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
      • About
      • Honorees
      • Ceremonies
      • Photos
      • Support
    • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
      • Resources
      • Exhibitions
      • Videos
    • Film
    • Literature
    • Performing Arts
  • Education
    • Center for Global Education
      • Professional Development
      • Educator Resources
      • Our Ideas
      • Asia Society at Home
      • Education For Equity
      • About
  • Policy
    • Asia Society Policy Institute
      • Topics
      • Regions
      • Events
      • About
      • Support Us
    • Center on U.S.-China Relations
      • Home
      • About
      • Projects
      • Reports
      • Past Events
      • ChinaFile
  • Initiatives
    • Arts
      • Arts & Museum Summit
      • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
      • Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network
      • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
      • U.S.-China Museum Summit
      • U.S.-Asia Entertainment Summit
    • Education
      • Center for Global Education
      • China Learning Initiatives
      • Global Cities Education Network
      • Global Learning Beyond School
      • International Studies Schools Network
    • Leadership
      • Asia Game Changer Awards
      • Asia 21 Young Leaders Initiative
      • Global Talent Initiatives
      • U.S.-China Dialogue
    • Policy
      • Asia Society Policy Institute
      • Center on U.S.-China Relations
    • Sustainability
      • Coal + ICe
  • Countries & Regions
    • Column One
      • Afghanistan

      • American Samoa

      • Armenia
      • Australia
      • Azerbaijan
      • Bahrain
      • Bangladesh

      • Bhutan

      • Brunei

      • Cambodia

      • Central Asia
      • China
      • Cook Islands

      • Cyprus
      • East Asia
      • East Timor
      • Fiji

      • French Polynesia

      • Georgia

      • Guam
    • Column Two
      • Hong Kong
      • India
      • Indonesia
      • Iran
      • Iraq
      • Israel
      • Japan
      • Jordan
      • Kazakhstan
      • Kiribati
      • Kuwait

      • Kyrgyzstan
      • Laos
      • Lebanon
      • Macau
      • Malaysia
      • Maldives
      • Marshall Islands
      • Micronesia

      • Mongolia

    • Column Three
      • Myanmar

      • Nauru

      • Nepal

      • New Caledonia

      • New Zealand

      • Niue
      • North Korea

      • Northern Marianas
      • Oceania
      • Oman

      • Pakistan

      • Palau
      • Palestine

      • Papua New Guinea
      • Philippines
      • Qatar

      • Samoa
      • Saudi Arabia
      • Singapore

      • Solomon Islands

    • Column Four
      • South Asia
      • Southeast Asia
      • South Korea
      • Sri Lanka
      • Syria
      • Taiwan
      • Tajikistan
      • Thailand
      • Tibet
      • Tokelau
      • Tonga
      • Turkey

      • Turkmenistan

      • Tuvalu
      • United Arab Emirates
      • Uzbekistan
      • Vanuatu
      • Vietnam
      • Wallis and Futuna
      • West Asia
      • Yemen
  • Current Affairs
    • Topics
      • Business
      • Environment
      • Governance
    • Programming
      • Beyond the Headlines
      • Business of Asia
    • Center on U.S.-China Relations
      • Home
      • About
      • Projects
      • Reports
      • Past Events
      • ChinaFile
  • Look & Listen
    • Asia Blog
    • ChinaFile
    • Podcasts
    • Video Gallery
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
  • Visit
    • Visit Us
      • Hong Kong
      • New York
      • Texas
    • Global Network
      • Australia
      • India
      • Japan
      • Korea
      • Northern California
      • Philippines
      • Southern California
      • Switzerland
      • Washington, DC
  • About
    • About Asia Society
    • Inclusion & Diversity
    • Mission & History
    • Co-Chairs and Trustees
    • Senior Leadership
    • Global Staff
    • Experts & Fellows
    • Global Council
    • Careers
    • Interns and Volunteers
    • Financial Statements
    • For the Media
      • Press Releases
  • Support
    • The Campaign for Asia Society
    • Corporate Engagement
      • Business Council
      • Global Talent and Diversity Council
      • Rising Executives Network
      • Enhancements to Membership
      • Corporate Membership
      • Global Corporate Leaders
    • Membership
    • Donate
ASIABLOG
Search
Search
  • Arts
    • Asia Society Museum
      • Visit
      • Exhibitions
      • Programs
      • Learn
      • Support
    • Arts & Museum Summit
    • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
      • About
      • Honorees
      • Ceremonies
      • Photos
      • Support
    • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
      • Resources
      • Exhibitions
      • Videos
    • Film
    • Literature
    • Performing Arts
  • Education
    • Center for Global Education
      • Professional Development
      • Educator Resources
      • Our Ideas
      • Asia Society at Home
      • Education For Equity
      • About
  • Policy
    • Asia Society Policy Institute
      • Topics
      • Regions
      • Events
      • About
      • Support Us
    • Center on U.S.-China Relations
      • Home
      • About
      • Projects
      • Reports
      • Past Events
      • ChinaFile
  • Initiatives
    • Arts
      • Arts & Museum Summit
      • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
      • Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network
      • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
      • U.S.-China Museum Summit
      • U.S.-Asia Entertainment Summit
    • Education
      • Center for Global Education
      • China Learning Initiatives
      • Global Cities Education Network
      • Global Learning Beyond School
      • International Studies Schools Network
    • Leadership
      • Asia Game Changer Awards
      • Asia 21 Young Leaders Initiative
      • Global Talent Initiatives
      • U.S.-China Dialogue
    • Policy
      • Asia Society Policy Institute
      • Center on U.S.-China Relations
    • Sustainability
      • Coal + ICe
  • Countries & Regions
    • Column One
      • Afghanistan

      • American Samoa

      • Armenia
      • Australia
      • Azerbaijan
      • Bahrain
      • Bangladesh

      • Bhutan

      • Brunei

      • Cambodia

      • Central Asia
      • China
      • Cook Islands

      • Cyprus
      • East Asia
      • East Timor
      • Fiji

      • French Polynesia

      • Georgia

      • Guam
    • Column Two
      • Hong Kong
      • India
      • Indonesia
      • Iran
      • Iraq
      • Israel
      • Japan
      • Jordan
      • Kazakhstan
      • Kiribati
      • Kuwait

      • Kyrgyzstan
      • Laos
      • Lebanon
      • Macau
      • Malaysia
      • Maldives
      • Marshall Islands
      • Micronesia

      • Mongolia

    • Column Three
      • Myanmar

      • Nauru

      • Nepal

      • New Caledonia

      • New Zealand

      • Niue
      • North Korea

      • Northern Marianas
      • Oceania
      • Oman

      • Pakistan

      • Palau
      • Palestine

      • Papua New Guinea
      • Philippines
      • Qatar

      • Samoa
      • Saudi Arabia
      • Singapore

      • Solomon Islands

    • Column Four
      • South Asia
      • Southeast Asia
      • South Korea
      • Sri Lanka
      • Syria
      • Taiwan
      • Tajikistan
      • Thailand
      • Tibet
      • Tokelau
      • Tonga
      • Turkey

      • Turkmenistan

      • Tuvalu
      • United Arab Emirates
      • Uzbekistan
      • Vanuatu
      • Vietnam
      • Wallis and Futuna
      • West Asia
      • Yemen
  • Current Affairs
    • Topics
      • Business
      • Environment
      • Governance
    • Programming
      • Beyond the Headlines
      • Business of Asia
    • Center on U.S.-China Relations
      • Home
      • About
      • Projects
      • Reports
      • Past Events
      • ChinaFile
  • Look & Listen
    • Asia Blog
    • ChinaFile
    • Podcasts
    • Video Gallery
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
  • Visit
    • Visit Us
      • Hong Kong
      • New York
      • Texas
    • Global Network
      • Australia
      • India
      • Japan
      • Korea
      • Northern California
      • Philippines
      • Southern California
      • Switzerland
      • Washington, DC
  • About
    • About Asia Society
    • Inclusion & Diversity
    • Mission & History
    • Co-Chairs and Trustees
    • Senior Leadership
    • Global Staff
    • Experts & Fellows
    • Global Council
    • Careers
    • Interns and Volunteers
    • Financial Statements
    • For the Media
      • Press Releases
  • Support
    • The Campaign for Asia Society
    • Corporate Engagement
      • Business Council
      • Global Talent and Diversity Council
      • Rising Executives Network
      • Enhancements to Membership
      • Corporate Membership
      • Global Corporate Leaders
    • Membership
    • Donate

What Should the Trump Administration Do in Asia? 11 Experts Weigh In

January 26th, 2017


Experts discuss what President Trump should do in Asia. (Elsa Ruiz/Asia Society)

President Trump has focused much of his first week in office on domestic policy. But the 45th president must soon turn to a large and complex set of foreign policy problems, including several centered around Asia: trade, nuclear proliferation, terrorism, and the world's most important bilateral relationship, with China.

Related

See all of Asia Society's ongoing coverage of the 45th president.Learn more

In order to tease out the most pressing Asia policy challenges for the new administration, Asia Society assembled an extraordinary panel of experts from across the military, academia, media, and private sector and asked them to provide advice to the president. Josette Sheeran, Asia Society President and CEO, and Kevin Rudd, president of the Asia Society Policy Institute, served as moderators.

Here were the panelists:

  • Hassan Abbas, professor of International Security Studies and chair of the Department of Regional and Analytical Studies at National Defense University, and Carnegie Fellow at New America  
  • Colonel Matthew Bogdanos, assistant district attorney in New York City and author of Thieves of Baghdad.
  • Scott Kennedy, deputy director of the Freeman Chair in China Studies, and director of the Project on Chinese Business and Political Economy at the Center for Strategic and International Studies 
  • Gheewhan Kim, consul general of the Republic of Korea in New York
  • Evan Medeiros, managing director for Eurasia Group's coverage of the Asia-Pacific.
  • Nazee Moinian, PhD candidate at St. Andrews University in Scotland and most recently a member of Hillary Clinton’s foreign policy advisory group on Iran.
  • Malcolm Nance, executive director of the Terror Asymmetrics Project on Strategy, Tactics and Radical Ideologies.
  • Orville Schell, Arthur Ross Director of the Center on U.S.-China Relations at Asia Society.
  • Paul Sheard, executive vice president and chief economist at Standard & Poor's Global.
  • Lulu Wang, founder and chief executive officer of Tupelo Capital Management, and trustee of the Asia Society.
  • Lally Weymouth, senior associate editor at the Washington Post.

The format was simple. Each panelist began with a 60-second "elevator pitch" to President Trump on a topic of their choice and then participated in an in-depth question and answer session centered around five broad topics: the U.S.-China relationship, trade and the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), terrorism, Iran, and North Korea. At the conclusion of each topic, Sheeran polled the audience to gauge their opinion of what the new president should do.

Despite the breadth of topics presented in the discussion, some common themes emerged. Many of the panelists urged President Trump to engage with, rather than retreat from, the region, focus on nuclear diplomacy with Iran and North Korea, and maintain American involvement in the Asia-Pacific economy through international trade.

Here's a taste of what the panelists said:

On U.S.-China Relations and the Surrounding Region

Medeiros: "Confrontation with China is not a strategy for China. Nobody wants to have to choose between the U.S. and China."

Schell: "Engagement has been our policy for decades. If we aren’t able to engage, what is our policy? And that’s a question that hasn’t been answered."

Kennedy: "We have to find a way to dial up the temperature a little bit, but show that this pressure isn't an end to itself. The U.S. can cohabitate and get along fine with a powerful China. It's not whether or not we use confrontation, it's how we signal the end goal with China."

Schell: "The Philippines has run off with China, and the South Korean government is in a state of disassembly. And so we’re left with Japan. At the same time, we’re finding individual countries running into political disaggregation and we’re seeing alliances and networks running into disaggregation. Look at the EU. Look at Brexit. We’re looking at a new very fractured, feudal view of the world, which I find quite alarming."

Medeiros: "The regional reaction is largely going to fall into two buckets: One is resilience, one is diversification. When it comes to allies like Australia, Japan, and South Korea, nobody is going to break off alliances in the United States. What you'll begin to see is a focus on their own domestic economic capabilities, their own domestic defense capabilities, and then begin to diversify security and economic partners so there's not such an exclusive alliance on the United States and U.S. institutions in the region.

Wang: "If I were in an elevator with President Trump, I'd make sure we'd have President Xi [Jinping] with us. And if we had both together, I'd tell them that the only way to any peace or collaboration is to give each other face."

On Trade and TPP

Weymouth: "By killing TPP, Trump sent a disturbing signal: The U.S. is withdrawing from Asia. In the end, if this persists, China will be the winner."

Sheard: "We've had Pax America for the last 60 years, we've had the U.S. be the global policeman, we've had the U.S. be the consumer of last resort opening up its markets to the world, and giving emerging and transitional economies access to this giant domestic market, and not always demanding, in exchange, reciprocity. And what I hear from the Trump administration is that those days are gone, and now everything has to be on an equal playing field — reciprocity."

Medeiros: "Come up with a real, serious alternative to TPP. If you don't like the TPP, fine. Change it, modify it, call it the Trump Pacific Partnership — who cares? But the region wants a multilateral solution, one that will bring about structural change."

On Terrorism and the Islamic State

Nance: "Islam has nothing to do with ISIS and al Qaeda. Those are religious cults that have corrupted Islam.”

Nance: "ISIS is almost physically defeated in Iraq and Syria — they have maybe one year left before they're totally eradicated from the mainland of the Middle East. In Egypt, they’re being whittled down. In Libya, we just decimated the last remaining stronghold of ISIS with a B-2 Bomber attack on President Obama's last night. In Afghanistan, the Taliban is actually reporting to us where ISIS base camps are."


Malcolm Nance discusses U.S. advancements in counterterrorism and why he's concerned President Trump's foreign policy will represent a setback. (Elsa Ruiz/Asia Society)

Bogdanos: "If you want to say that we'll eliminate terrorism by eliminating poverty, you won't. It's simply one of the causes. Far too many of those engaging in horrible acts are upper middle class, well-educated people from Western democracies. So that's not the answer." 

Abbas: "We've come to a nuanced understanding about counterterrorism, which is based on building partnerships with progressive elements within Muslim societies. So don't try to reinvent the wheel. Build on what we've already accomplished."

On Iran

Moinian: "We have much more in common with Iran than we have differences. We can use Iran to fight ISIS, to fight terrorism, and to safeguard to the Persian Gulf. President Trump should reach out to civil society and build a bridge so that he can empower them and build a future."

Moinian: "Engagement is not appeasement. Engagement means calibrated, introspective, and very deliberate steps to bring a proud and civilized nation back into the fold."

Nance: "If President Trump rips up the Iranian nuclear deal, that gives Iran free reign to go back to the 10-month breakout period they had from the 15-year period we negotiated. That means Iran could go back and try to make a bomb in the next year or two."

On North Korea

Rudd: "The Iranian nuclear program is just a baby compared to the North Korean program."

Kim: "All of the United Nations Security Council members have agreed to sanctions for North Korea, but we need to go much further. Strategic patience may have been good diplomacy, but it cannot denuclearize the country."

Medeiros: "One of the poorly understood aspects of the North Korean problem is that there are tools, secondary sanctions, that could really squeeze the Kim regime. The tricky part is that it'd require a high degree of compliance from China, and it'd require China to feel some pain. And it'd require China to stomach the fact that there'd be more instability on their North Korean border."

Related Links

  • Podcast: Donald Trump and Asia
  • Memos to Donald Trump
donald trump
advice
politics
policy
asia society policy institute
kevin rudd
josette sheeran
asia blog
hassan abbas
lulu wang
matthew bogdanos
orville schell
evan medeiros
scott kennedy
paul sheard
u.s.-china relations
nuclear weapons
hillary clinton
kim jong un
taliban
isis
islamic state
tpp
trade
al qaeda
malcolm nance
nazee moinian
lally weymouth
gheewan kim
about partners subscribe

About the Author

Profile picture for user Matt Schiavenza

Matt Schiavenza is the Assistant Director of Content at Asia Society. His work has appeared at The Atlantic, The Daily Beast, The New Republic, Fortune, and strategy + business among other publications.

Contents

  • Arts
  • Business
  • Current Affairs
  • Education
  • Food & Recipes
  • Lifestyle
  • Multimedia
  • Policy

Featured Posts

Suharto
Q&A: Vincent Bevins on How Indonesia’s Anti-Communist Campaign Shaped the Modern World
Doctors treat a patient infected with COVID-19
A Pulmonary Physician on What It's Like To Treat COVID-19 Patients
A scene from Never Have I Ever
'Never Have I Ever' Star Poorna Jagannathan on Saying No to Roles Portraying Indian Caricatures
Alan Yang Asian In-Depth
Asia In-Depth Podcast: A Conversation With Writer and Director Alan Yang
Facebook
We Know Asia,
Get to Know Us

Visit Us

  • Hong Kong
  • New York
  • Texas

Global Network

  • Australia
  • India
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Northern California
  • Philippines
  • Southern California
  • Switzerland
  • Washington, DC

Resources

  • Arts
  • Asia Blog
  • ChinaFile
  • Current Affairs
  • Education
  • For Kids
  • Policy
  • Video

Shop

  • AsiaStore

Initiatives

  • Arts & Museum Summit
  • Asia 21 Young Leaders
  • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
  • Asia Game Changer Awards
  • Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network
  • Asia Society Policy Institute
  • Center for Global Education
  • Center on U.S.-China Relations
  • China Learning Initiatives
  • Coal + Ice
  • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
  • Global Cities Education Network
  • Global Learning Beyond School
  • Global Talent Initiatives
  • Int'l Studies Schools Network
  • U.S.-Asia Entertainment Summit
  • U.S.-China Dialogue
  • U.S.-China Museum Summit

About Asia Society

  • Mission & History
  • Our People
  • Become a Member
  • Career Opportunities
  • Corporate Involvement

Connect

  • Email Signup
  • For the Media

©2021 Asia Society | Privacy Statement | Accessibility | About AsiaSociety.org | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap | Contact

Asia Society takes no institutional position on policy issues and has no affiliation with any government.
The views expressed by Asia Society staff, fellows, experts, report authors, program speakers, board members, and other affiliates are solely their own. Learn more.

 

 

  • Visit Us
  • Hong Kong
  • New York
  • Texas
  • Global Network
  • Australia
  • India
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Northern California
  • Philippines
  • Southern California
  • Switzerland
  • Washington, DC