How the World Recruits Teachers | Asia Society Skip to main content

Unsupported Browser Detected.
It seems the web browser you're using doesn't support some of the features of this site. For the best experience, we recommend using a modern browser that supports the features of this website. We recommend Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Microsoft Edge

  • Professional Development
    • Global Ed Explorer
    • Online Courses
  • Educator Resources
    • Teaching for Global Understanding
  • About the Network
    • Meeting History & Agendas
    • Approach and Impact
    • Reports
  • About the Center for Global Education
    • Who We Are
    • Where We Work
    • Results and Opportunities
    • News and Events
Search
Global Cities Education Network
  • Professional Development
    • Global Ed Explorer
    • Online Courses
  • Educator Resources
    • Teaching for Global Understanding
  • About the Network
    • Meeting History & Agendas
    • Approach and Impact
    • Reports
  • About the Center for Global Education
    • Who We Are
    • Where We Work
    • Results and Opportunities
    • News and Events

How the World Recruits Teachers

A student smiles (maliketh/istockphoto)

Teachers are no longer expected simply to deliver information to the next generation. The role of the teacher is changing to meet the expectations of a global society for well-prepared knowledge workers who can synthesize information, identify and solve problems, create the next innovations in their given fields, work in teams, and make positive contributions to civil society.

With these new realities, the recruitment of public school teachers have compelled new practices throughout the world.

In some countries, the hiring of teachers has moved from the Ministry to the prefecture or municipality and in others from there to the school.  However, in most countries, the central government still dictates the requirements individuals must meet to be selected as teachers. 

There are two variations on the teacher recruitment and selection process: some countries exercise selectivity by limiting the number of people who are accepted into a teacher training program, while others allow many students to participate in teacher training and then use an examination system to select the top candidates based first on an examination score and then on an interview and a practical exercise of teaching prowess. Korea uses a combination of the two as it limits the number of places and exercises selectivity for entry into teacher preparation programs for students to prepare to become elementary school teachers, while it sets no limits for students interested in becoming secondary school teachers: all can enter a preparation program though only 20 percent find employment as secondary school teachers. Many are concerned that this will lead the best-prepared secondary students to select a field other than education to raise the likelihood of getting a job.

The two methods of selectivity have different recruitment strategies. Limiting access to preparation programs is one form of recruitment as students seek to enter more selective and prestigious programs. In addition, the limitations on entry are correlated to expected vacancies so graduating students hold a high expectation of finding a position. Since prefectures or municipalities make the selection, the student is guaranteed a job, but not a job in a specific school. In many eastern countries, such as Japan, Korea and Singapore, teachers are rotated to different schools every five to seven years, so the assignment to a specific school is not considered a critical issue. However, the other side of the coin is that there is little competition among candidates for job positions. In Korea, elementary schools have barely as many candidates as there are teaching vacancies.

In systems where the supply of teachers is far greater than the demand as in Japan and secondary schools in Korea, the issue of selection is more important than that of recruitment as generally understood in western countries where demand far outstrips supply. In Japan, the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology requires the prefectural boards of education to place a great focus on the job interview in addition to the written appointment examination. This is to ensure that the teachers exhibit the dimensions of character and mission that are important to effective teaching.

In Korea, a similar interest has developed to go beyond the employment examination score to include interviews and practical demonstrations of teaching expertise. However, there have been a number of criticisms of the “formalistic” nature of the interview, necessitated by the large number of candidates for each position. The government allows input from current teachers and parents and is considering external evaluation of the instructional skills of teacher candidates.

Western countries have faced a more difficult task in recruiting teachers because teachers are not generally held in as high esteem there as in eastern nations. Teacher education programs draw their students more often from the lower third of the college class than any other segment. While student populations have become more diverse over the last twenty years, the teacher candidate pool has not. This has led to a number of different recruitment practices.

In New South Wales in Australia, prospective teachers of mathematics, science and technology can receive scholarship awards of A$10,000 in their senior year to commit to teach for two years in a remote area. In Western Australia, the Catholic Education Office actively recruits teacher candidates with a serious calling to service to teach children in remote areas. The Kimberly Calling program provides a strong induction and cultural awareness program and requires a time commitment.

In Denmark teachers receive special allowances, including free accommodations and home computers, for their willingness to teach in remote areas. In France, the Ministry has offered special job placements for beginning teachers who have taken specialized courses in school improvement to go as a five-person team to priority schools with economically disadvantaged students.

In the United Kingdom, prospective teachers in hard-to-fill subject areas can receive up to £5,000 for preparing to teach in those areas. In addition, these new teachers receive a “Golden Hello” one-time stipend of £4,000 upon successfully completing their first year of teaching. In the United States, the federal government offers loan forgiveness of up to $17,500 for teachers in areas of mathematics, science, special education. However, this amount does not attract students from the best universities who may have loans of much higher amounts and look for higher paying professions as a result. Many school districts offer small incentive pay stipends to recruit teachers in areas of mathematics, science, special education. However, theses stipends have not had a large impact.

As a different strategy, US states have developed alternative certification programs (ACP) which allow college students to pursue a major in a specific subject area and then upon graduation participate in an ACP. The programs offer a summer course session followed by on-the-job training during the first two years of teaching. Teachers are fully certified at the end of the second year. This has enabled school districts to recruit not only people with better academic preparation, but has also encouraged mid-career professionals to change careers and enter teaching. Such a program in New York City has greatly reduced the vacancy problem in inner city schools.

This article was written by Dr. Susan F. Sclafani. It was edited for the web. Read the full article, including references.

Discussion

Dr. Sclafani summarized different teacher recruitment practices from throughout the world. Do the high-performing nations have the best strategies? What other factors contribute to recruitment strategies? What international practices, if any, should US schools of education adopt?

You Might Also Like

  • Future of Teaching and Learning 2019
    report
     /  Education

    The Future of Teaching and Learning

    Read the report from the 2019 International Summit on the Teaching Profession, which focused on the future of teaching and learning.
  • Cover of the 2018 International Summit of the Teaching Profession report
    report
     /  Education

    New Challenges and Opportunities Facing the Teaching Profession in Public Education

    Read the report from the 2018 International Summit on the Teaching Profession, which focused on new challenges and opportunities for educators in public education.
  • Edinburgh with the ISTP 2017 logo
    report
     /  Education

    Empowering and Enabling Teachers to Improve Equity and Outcomes for All

    The 2017 International Summit on the Teaching Profession focused on sustainable excellence and equity in learning.
  • 2016 International Summit on the Teaching Profession
    report
     /  Education

    Creating the Conditions to Achieve Quality Teaching for Excellent Learning Outcomes

    How can we create the conditions to achieve quality teaching for excellent and equitable learning outcomes? The 2016 International Summit on the Teaching Profession looked to answer this question.
  • GCEN CTE Working Group participants on a Shanghai school visit. (Asia Society)

    Learning Across National Boundaries

    Amelia Peterson and Jal Mehta are investigating the learning experiences of participants in international learning communities, including Asia Society's Global Cities Education Network.
  • International Summit on the Teaching Profession: 2015 Summit
    report
     /  Education

    Implementing Highly Effective Teacher Policy and Practice

    How does education move from dialogue to action in the context of complex systems and multiple political, economic, and social imperatives? A new report offers recommendations.
  • Education officials at the 2014 International Summit on the Teaching Profession.
    report
     /  Education

    Excellence, Equity, and Inclusiveness: High Quality Teaching for All

    How can education systems achieve both excellence and equity? A new report offers recommendations.
  • Education officials at the 2013 International Summit on the Teaching Profession
    report
     /  Education

    Teacher Evaluation: An International Perspective

    Teachers are nation builders. How do we know they are effective—and how can we support them?
  • Students raising their hands. (urbancow/iStockPhoto)
    Education

    Equity and Quality in Education

    Get the key policy recommendations from this OECD report.
  • Students explore nature together (dcdebs/iStockPhoto)
    report
     /  Education

    Teaching and Learning 21st Century Skills

    How students learn 21st century skills and the pedagogy needed for new learning styles.
  • 2012 International Summit on the Teaching Profession
    report
     /  Education

    Teaching and Leadership for the 21st Century

    US Department of Education hosts a meeting on how the world's best school systems prepare and elevate teachers.
  • (US Department of Education)
    report
     /  Education

    Improving Teacher Quality Around the World

    A groundbreaking report summarizes international summit discussions and emerging lessons.
  • A student smiles (maliketh/istockphoto)

    How the World Recruits Teachers

    Recruiting great teachers is critically important. See how successful nations go about it.
  • From Closing the Talent Gap report. (McKinsey & Company)
    report
     /  Education

    New Strategies Needed for Teacher Recruitment

    Every teacher in the best school systems in the world graduated at the top of the class. Not so in the United States.
  • International Summit on the Teaching Profession
    series

    International Summit on the Teaching Profession

    When top educators around the world get together to share ideas, big things happen.

Related Content

  • report

    Early Teacher Development

    New report highlights global best practices in recruiting and inducting new teachers into the teaching profession.
  • report

    Teacher Evaluation: An International Perspective

    Teachers are nation builders. How do we know they are effective—and how can we support them?
  • Advice from Asia: Invest in Teachers

    Asia Society gathered the education ministers from top education systems. Here's their advice.
  • World's Education Leaders to Meet

    Teachers, ministers, and other education leaders to gather for summit on teaching profession.
  • How the World Recruits Teachers

    Recruiting great teachers is critically important. See how successful nations go about it.

Videos

  • Education

    Global Ed Explorer

    An affordable and engaging way to give educators access to the Center for Global Education’s renowned global competence content.
    Watch Now
  • Education

    TEQ Video: Chunman Xie's First Grade Novice-Mid Chinese Class in Colorado

    Chinese language teacher Chunman Xie demonstrates how to identify food items, select healthy food, and express opinions in Chinese.
    Watch Now
  • Education

    TEQ Video: Grace Pei's Grades 9-10 Novice-High to Intermediate-Low Chinese Class - 'Asking for and giving directions'

    Chinese language teacher Grace Pei demonstrates how to teach a common skill such as asking for directions by guiding students step by step to learn and practice new language skills in context.
    Watch Now
  • Education

    TEQ Video: Catherine Zhong's High School Chinese Class - the Impact of the Internet

    A teacher embeds language learning into well-connected and highly interactive learning experiences.
    Watch Now
  • Education

    Guo Ruijian's Elementary School Novice-Mid Chinese Class in North Carolina

    Chinese language teacher Guo Ruijian helps her students discuss buying fruit in Mandarin.
    Watch Now
About
  • Mission & History
  • Our People
  • Become a Member
  • Career Opportunities
  • Corporate Involvement
visit us
  • Hong Kong
  • New York
  • Texas
global network
  • Australia
  • France
  • India
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Northern California
  • Philippines
  • Seattle
  • Southern California
  • Switzerland
  • Washington, D.C.
resources
  • Arts
  • Asia Society Magazine
  • ChinaFile
  • Education
  • Policy
  • Video
shop
  • AsiaStore
initiatives
  • Arts & Museum Summit
  • Asia 21 Next Generation Fellows
  • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
  • Asia Game Changer Awards
  • Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network
  • Asia Society Policy Institute
  • Asian Women Empowered
  • Center on U.S.-China Relations
  • Coal + Ice
  • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
  • Global Cities Education Network
  • Global Talent Initiatives
  • U.S.-Asia Entertainment Summit
  • U.S.-China Dialogue
  • U.S.-China Museum Summit
Connect
Email Signup For the media
Asia Society logo
©2023 Asia Society | Privacy Statement | Accessibility | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap | Contact

Asia Society takes no institutional position on policy issues and has no affiliation with any government.
The views expressed by Asia Society staff, fellows, experts, report authors, program speakers, board members, and other affiliates are solely their own. Learn more.

 

 

  • Visit Us
  • Hong Kong
  • New York
  • Texas
  • Global Network
  • Australia
  • France
  • India
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Northern California
  • Philippines
  • Seattle
  • Southern California
  • Switzerland
  • Washington, DC