The Korean Judge | Asia Society Skip to main content

Unsupported Browser Detected.
It seems the web browser you're using doesn't support some of the features of this site. For the best experience, we recommend using a modern browser that supports the features of this website. We recommend Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Microsoft Edge

  • Chinese Language Learning
    • Mandarin Jumpstart
    • National Chinese Language Conference
    • Teaching Resources Hub
    • Language Learning Supporters
  • Global Education
    • About Global Competence
    • Global Competency Resources
    • Teaching for Global Understanding
    • Discover Asia
    • Thought Leadership
  • About
    • About
    • Results and Opportunities
    • News and Events
Search
Education
  • Chinese Language Learning
    • Mandarin Jumpstart
    • National Chinese Language Conference
    • Teaching Resources Hub
    • Language Learning Supporters
  • Global Education
    • About Global Competence
    • Global Competency Resources
    • Teaching for Global Understanding
    • Discover Asia
    • Thought Leadership
  • About
    • About
    • Results and Opportunities
    • News and Events

The Korean Judge

Supreme Court of South Korea

Koreans, like their neighbors the Chinese and the Japanese, traditionally avoided lawsuits. They settled their differences informally through family or community organizations. In Japan, Taiwan, and the People's Republic of China, out-of-court mediation is much more common than a lawsuit. Koreans also share this preference, but their mediation process takes a different form.

Koreans' preference for mediation comes in part from their Confucian heritage. Confucians believed the very existence of unlawful behavior indicated a failure of the moral system and ethical example of the king. At best the development of legal procedure was a regrettable necessity. Using lawsuits to solve problems was extremely undesirable, and this attitude was reinforced by negative features of Korea's traditional legal system. Trials were slow and expensive, and in the case of criminal trials where torture was legal, even physically dangerous. For both moral and practical reasons, mediation was the best way to settle disputes.

In mediation a third person (the mediator) helps resolve a dispute without authority to impose a decision; disputing parties are free to ignore or reject the mediator's suggestions. In Western lawsuits the disputing parties surrender their right to decide, and only the judge or jury hands down a decision. In Korean lawsuits the judge in a formal court, as powerful and active in the courtroom as our own, mediates more than he judges.

At first the Korean judge, clad in black robes, seated on a raised platform in front of the courtroom, looks like an American judge, with all the trappings of our own courts of law. But often a Korean trial does not result in a verdict. Actually, the courtroom in Korea is less a setting for lawsuits than a forum where people air grievances before an objective third person. The judge, really a mediator, helps them reach an amicable solution.

In other East Asian countries there are more opportunities for pre-trial mediation. In Japan, for instance, the police play an extremely important role as informal mediators, and many disputes are resolved quickly at the neighborhood police station. But Korea has fewer pre-trial procedures available and the police are unpopular. So, informal mediation occurs in a more formal setting.

Generally, Korean judges, lawyers, as well as the disputing parties believe that going to court, are to be avoided if at all possible. The only prospect worse than ending up in court is prolonging the stay. Judges assume that most people really prefer to resolve their disputes with as little conflict as possible and will welcome the opportunity to compromise.

Korean legal practice emphasizes discovering the facts in the case rather than hearing competitive arguments, as in our courtrooms. Unlike an American, the Korean judge serves as chief questioner of all witnesses. He offers suggestions, expresses opinions and controls the hearings even when lawyers are present. He determines right and wrong and acts as a truth-seeking specialist empowered to get to the bottom of the trouble. The lying witness should be exposed, the cunning plaintiff thwarted and the ignorant defendant allowed a fair hearing.

Most Koreans represent themselves and do not hire a lawyer in civil lawsuits. Lawyers, when they are present, play a secondary role. Lawyers begin their careers as judges and then retire into private legal practice, the opposite of our system. Lawyers are often decades older than judges and see themselves as colleagues who advise and help the judge. The judge discovers the truth; the lawyers advise him and help their clients through the bureaucratic maze. Since most lawyers began as judges, they identify more with the judges than with their clients.

The modern Korean judge embodies many traditions of the old district magistrate who adopted a fatherly role toward people under his rule. Traditional Korea had no use for lawyers. Those who made a living drawing up legal documents or representing people before the magistrate were seen as obstructors of justice. They were thought of as crooks, who instigated lawsuits, fabricated evidence and hindered the work of the magistrate, whose job was to solve the crime or resolve the dispute. Offering legal advice for a fee was, in fact, severely restricted by law in Korea until 1905. The lawyer now has more dignity but is relegated to a secondary position.

An American judge acts as impartial referee, weighing the arguments skillfully represented by professionals, but in Korea the judge alone is responsible for the realization of justice. His part in the trial is consistent with the traditional role of magistrate; he acts as a mediator, the natural ally of honest people. Since the style of the Korean judge lends itself to mediation, what starts as a Western style trial easily shifts to encourage reconciliation. The judge is supported in his efforts toward compromise by the lawyers, and the compromise agreement is considered an official court document with the same legal force as a judge's verdict.

Author: Linda Lewis.

Additional Background Reading on Asia

  • China's world cup fans
    article

    China’s World Cup 'Craze'

    Why were there so many Chinese fans in the bleachers at this year's FIFA World Cup, when the Chinese team wasn’t even on the field? Student Jerry Tian gives us his perspective.
  • A mural of Kim Il Sung in the foreground (Anne Hilton)

    North Korea: Looking Beyond the Stereotypes

    We've compiled resources to help you cut through the stereotypes surrounding North Korea and more deeply examine the country, its people, and the complexities of its politics and nuclear program.
  • Tsinghua University, East Gate

    China's Education System: The Oldest in the World

    It may sound incredible, but China’s formal education system—the oldest in the world—was established nearly two millennia ago.
  • October 9 is the only national holiday dedicated to a writing system.

    The World's Most Incredible Alphabet

    Hint: It was invented to fit a language that previously used a borrowed writing system.
  • Folio from a Ashtasahashirika Prajnaparamita Manuscript

    Visualize the World

    Museum resources and educational resources that help students develop visual literacy and a better understanding of the world.
  • Tang Dynasty copy of 新婦地黃湯帖 by Wang Xianzhi (Taito Ward Calligraphy Museum). Image is in the public domain.

    Revelations from the Brush

    A case for practicing calligraphy from one learner's perspective.
  • A painting that has traces of the three teachings (Metropolitan Museum of Art)

    The Three Teachings

    How Confucianism, Daoism, and Buddhism complement one another. Read on to learn about the "fourth teaching."
  • A Tibetan mantra inscribed in rocks at Zanskar, India. Photographer unknown.

    Math, Science, and Technology in India

    A tour de force essay written by Dr. Roddham Narasimha.
  • Ralph Waldo Emerson. (Etching by Sam W. Rowse, 1878)
    article

    Indian Influences on Western Literature

    Includes case studies on Ralph Waldo Emerson, T.S. Eliot, Herman Hesse, and The Beatles. A must-read!
  • Sarkhej Roza (Tomb & Mosque Of Ahmad Khattu Ganj Bakhsh) in India.

    Islamic Belief Made Visual

    On Islam and the use of geometric patterns.

Pagination

  • Current page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Page 6
  • Page 7
  • Page 8
  • Page 9
  • Next page Next
  • Last page Last

Related Content

  • The World's Most Incredible Alphabet

    Hint: It was invented to fit a language that previously used a borrowed writing system.
  • Japan's Sins of Omission

    International dispute over history textbooks in East Asia.
  • article

    Women's Role in Contemporary Korea

    An essay about Korean women's role in society and its rapid change in the last century.
  • article

    The Value and Meaning of the Korean Family

    An essay exploring why close family ties and dependencies are valued so highly in Korea.
  • article

    The Korean Judge

    The practice of mediation in Korea.

Videos

  • Current Affairs
     /  Northern California

    Marking the 10th Anniversary of the Korea-U.S. Free Trade Agreement: Strengthening Economic and Technology Ties

    Wendy Cutler and Jong-Hoon Kim discuss trade, partnership, and the current state of the two countries' economic relations.
    Watch Now
  • Arts
     /  Southern California

    Asia Society Southern California 2022 Annual Gala: 'Cultural Visionaries' Pachinko

    Awkwafina presents the award to the cast of the critically-acclaimed TV series.
    Watch Now
  • Arts
     /  France

    Why Speak of Asian Art in Paris?

    Eric Lefebvre of the Cernuschi Museum presents selected masterpieces from Asia.
    Watch Now
  • Current Affairs
     /  Korea

    Election Special: Congratulations From South Korea's Foreign Diplomatic Community

    Heads of missions in South Korea express their good wishes for the country's new president.
    Watch Now
  • Current Affairs
     /  Korea

    The Russia-Ukraine War as Case Study: Lessons for Northeast Asia

    Yvonne Kim talks to a panel of experts to get their thoughts on Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and its implications on the Korean peninsula.
    Watch Now
About
  • Mission & History
  • Our People
  • Become a Member
  • Career Opportunities
  • Corporate Involvement
visit us
  • Hong Kong
  • New York
  • Texas
global network
  • Australia
  • France
  • India
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Northern California
  • Philippines
  • Southern California
  • Switzerland
  • Washington, D.C.
resources
  • Arts
  • Asia Society Magazine
  • ChinaFile
  • Current Affairs
  • Education
  • For Kids
  • Policy
  • Video
shop
  • AsiaStore
initiatives
  • Arts & Museum Summit
  • Asia 21 Young Leaders
  • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
  • Asia Game Changer Awards
  • Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network
  • Asia Society Policy Institute
  • Asian Women Empowered
  • Center on U.S.-China Relations
  • Coal + Ice
  • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
  • Global Cities Education Network
  • Global Talent Initiatives
  • U.S.-Asia Entertainment Summit
  • U.S.-China Dialogue
  • U.S.-China Museum Summit
Connect
Email Signup For the media
Asia Society logo
©2023 Asia Society | Privacy Statement | Accessibility | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap | Contact

Asia Society takes no institutional position on policy issues and has no affiliation with any government.
The views expressed by Asia Society staff, fellows, experts, report authors, program speakers, board members, and other affiliates are solely their own. Learn more.

 

 

  • Visit Us
  • Hong Kong
  • New York
  • Texas
  • Global Network
  • Australia
  • France
  • India
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Northern California
  • Philippines
  • Southern California
  • Switzerland
  • Washington, DC