Four Questions for This Week's Trump-Xi Summit | Asia Society Skip to main content

Unsupported Browser Detected.
It seems the web browser you're using doesn't support some of the features of this site. For the best experience, we recommend using a modern browser that supports the features of this website. We recommend Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Microsoft Edge

  • Policy
    • Asia Society Policy Institute
      • Center for China Analysis
      • Topics
      • Countries & Regions
      • Publications
      • Initiatives
      • Watch & Listen
      • Events
      • About
      • Support Us
    • Center on U.S.-China Relations
      • Home
      • About
      • Projects
      • Events
      • Reports
      • COAL + ICE
      • ChinaFile
  • Arts
    • Asia Society Museum
      • Visit
      • Exhibitions
      • Programs
      • Collection
      • Asia Society Triennial
      • The Asia Arts and Museum Network
      • Learn
      • Support
    • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
      • About
      • Honorees
      • Ceremonies
      • Photos
      • Support
    • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
      • Resources
      • Exhibitions
      • Videos
    • Film
    • Literature
    • Performing Arts
  • Education
    • Chinese Language Learning
    • Global Competency Resources
    • About
  • Initiatives
    • Arts
      • Arts & Museum Summit
      • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
      • Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network
      • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
      • U.S.-China Museum Summit
      • U.S.-Asia Entertainment Summit
    • Education
      • Chinese Language Learning
      • About
    • Leadership
      • Asia Game Changer Awards
      • Asia 21 Young Leaders Initiative
      • Diversity Leadership Initiatives
      • U.S.-China Dialogue
    • Policy
      • Asia Society Policy Institute
      • Center on U.S.-China Relations
    • Sustainability
      • Asia Society Policy Institute
      • Coal + Ice
  • Countries & Regions
    • Column One
      • Afghanistan
      • American Samoa
      • Armenia
      • Australia
      • Azerbaijan
      • Bahrain
      • Bangladesh
      • Bhutan
      • Brunei
      • Cambodia
      • Central Asia
      • China
      • Cook Islands

      • Cyprus
      • East Asia
      • East Timor
      • Fiji
      • French Polynesia
      • Georgia
      • Guam
    • Column Two
      • Hong Kong
      • India
      • Indonesia
      • Iran
      • Iraq
      • Israel
      • Japan
      • Jordan
      • Kazakhstan
      • Kiribati
      • Kuwait
      • Kyrgyzstan
      • Laos
      • Lebanon
      • Macau
      • Malaysia
      • Maldives
      • Marshall Islands
      • Micronesia
      • Mongolia
    • Column Three
      • Myanmar
      • Nauru
      • Nepal
      • New Caledonia
      • New Zealand
      • Niue
      • North Korea
      • Northern Marianas
      • Oceania
      • Oman
      • Pakistan
      • Palau
      • Palestine
      • Papua New Guinea
      • Philippines
      • Qatar
      • Samoa
      • Saudi Arabia
      • Singapore
      • Solomon Islands
    • Column Four
      • South Asia
      • Southeast Asia
      • South Korea
      • Sri Lanka
      • Syria
      • Taiwan
      • Tajikistan
      • Thailand
      • Tibet
      • Tokelau
      • Tonga
      • Turkey
      • Turkmenistan
      • Tuvalu
      • United Arab Emirates
      • Uzbekistan
      • Vanuatu
      • Vietnam
      • Wallis and Futuna
      • West Asia
      • Yemen
  • Current Affairs
    • Topics
      • Business
      • Climate Change
      • Governance
    • Programming
      • Beyond the Headlines
      • Business of Asia
    • Center on U.S.-China Relations
      • Home
      • About
      • Projects
      • Reports
      • Past Events
      • ChinaFile
  • Look & Listen
    • Asia Society Magazine
    • ChinaFile
    • Podcasts
    • Video Gallery
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
  • Visit
    • Visit Us
      • Hong Kong
      • New York
      • Texas
    • Global Network
      • Australia
      • France
      • India
      • Japan
      • Korea
      • Northern California
      • Philippines
      • Southern California
      • Switzerland
      • Washington, D.C.
  • About
    • About Asia Society
    • Inclusion & Diversity
    • Background & History
    • Board of Trustees
    • Senior Leadership
    • Global Staff
    • Global Council
    • Careers
    • Interns and Volunteers
    • Financial Statements
    • For the Media
      • Press Releases
  • Support
    • The Campaign for Asia Society
    • Corporate Engagement
      • Business Council
      • Technology and Innovation Council
      • Global Talent and Diversity Council
      • Rising Executives Network
      • Enhancements to Membership
      • Corporate Membership
      • Global Corporate Leaders
    • Membership
    • Donate
    • Donor Privacy Statement
ASIABLOG
Subscribe
Search
  • Policy
    • Asia Society Policy Institute
      • Center for China Analysis
      • Topics
      • Countries & Regions
      • Publications
      • Initiatives
      • Watch & Listen
      • Events
      • About
      • Support Us
    • Center on U.S.-China Relations
      • Home
      • About
      • Projects
      • Events
      • Reports
      • COAL + ICE
      • ChinaFile
  • Arts
    • Asia Society Museum
      • Visit
      • Exhibitions
      • Programs
      • Collection
      • Asia Society Triennial
      • The Asia Arts and Museum Network
      • Learn
      • Support
    • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
      • About
      • Honorees
      • Ceremonies
      • Photos
      • Support
    • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
      • Resources
      • Exhibitions
      • Videos
    • Film
    • Literature
    • Performing Arts
  • Education
    • Chinese Language Learning
    • Global Competency Resources
    • About
  • Initiatives
    • Arts
      • Arts & Museum Summit
      • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
      • Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network
      • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
      • U.S.-China Museum Summit
      • U.S.-Asia Entertainment Summit
    • Education
      • Chinese Language Learning
      • About
    • Leadership
      • Asia Game Changer Awards
      • Asia 21 Young Leaders Initiative
      • Diversity Leadership Initiatives
      • U.S.-China Dialogue
    • Policy
      • Asia Society Policy Institute
      • Center on U.S.-China Relations
    • Sustainability
      • Asia Society Policy Institute
      • Coal + Ice
  • Countries & Regions
    • Column One
      • Afghanistan
      • American Samoa
      • Armenia
      • Australia
      • Azerbaijan
      • Bahrain
      • Bangladesh
      • Bhutan
      • Brunei
      • Cambodia
      • Central Asia
      • China
      • Cook Islands

      • Cyprus
      • East Asia
      • East Timor
      • Fiji
      • French Polynesia
      • Georgia
      • Guam
    • Column Two
      • Hong Kong
      • India
      • Indonesia
      • Iran
      • Iraq
      • Israel
      • Japan
      • Jordan
      • Kazakhstan
      • Kiribati
      • Kuwait
      • Kyrgyzstan
      • Laos
      • Lebanon
      • Macau
      • Malaysia
      • Maldives
      • Marshall Islands
      • Micronesia
      • Mongolia
    • Column Three
      • Myanmar
      • Nauru
      • Nepal
      • New Caledonia
      • New Zealand
      • Niue
      • North Korea
      • Northern Marianas
      • Oceania
      • Oman
      • Pakistan
      • Palau
      • Palestine
      • Papua New Guinea
      • Philippines
      • Qatar
      • Samoa
      • Saudi Arabia
      • Singapore
      • Solomon Islands
    • Column Four
      • South Asia
      • Southeast Asia
      • South Korea
      • Sri Lanka
      • Syria
      • Taiwan
      • Tajikistan
      • Thailand
      • Tibet
      • Tokelau
      • Tonga
      • Turkey
      • Turkmenistan
      • Tuvalu
      • United Arab Emirates
      • Uzbekistan
      • Vanuatu
      • Vietnam
      • Wallis and Futuna
      • West Asia
      • Yemen
  • Current Affairs
    • Topics
      • Business
      • Climate Change
      • Governance
    • Programming
      • Beyond the Headlines
      • Business of Asia
    • Center on U.S.-China Relations
      • Home
      • About
      • Projects
      • Reports
      • Past Events
      • ChinaFile
  • Look & Listen
    • Asia Society Magazine
    • ChinaFile
    • Podcasts
    • Video Gallery
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
  • Visit
    • Visit Us
      • Hong Kong
      • New York
      • Texas
    • Global Network
      • Australia
      • France
      • India
      • Japan
      • Korea
      • Northern California
      • Philippines
      • Southern California
      • Switzerland
      • Washington, D.C.
  • About
    • About Asia Society
    • Inclusion & Diversity
    • Background & History
    • Board of Trustees
    • Senior Leadership
    • Global Staff
    • Global Council
    • Careers
    • Interns and Volunteers
    • Financial Statements
    • For the Media
      • Press Releases
  • Support
    • The Campaign for Asia Society
    • Corporate Engagement
      • Business Council
      • Technology and Innovation Council
      • Global Talent and Diversity Council
      • Rising Executives Network
      • Enhancements to Membership
      • Corporate Membership
      • Global Corporate Leaders
    • Membership
    • Donate
    • Donor Privacy Statement

Four Questions for This Week's Trump-Xi Summit

April 4th, 2017


Chinese President Xi Jinping will meet American President Donald Trump in Florida on Thursday for a two-day summit.(Fabrice Coffini/AFP/Getty Images)

On Thursday, U.S. President Donald Trump will welcome Xi Jinping, his Chinese counterpart, to Trump’s Mar-a-Lago resort in south Florida for a two-day summit. The gathering marks the first meeting between Trump and Xi, leaders of the world’s two largest economies — this, alone, makes it a high-profile gathering.

Before the summit kicks off, what are the key issues at play? Here are some questions to consider.

What is the purpose of these summits? What do they accomplish?

The summit meeting between Xi and President Barack Obama at the Sunnylands estate in Rancho Mirage, California, in 2013 — the direct antecedent to this week’s summit — resulted in few tangible changes to the U.S.-China relationship. This was largely by design. The Sunnylands summit instead provided a relaxed setting for the two leaders to exchange ideas and get to know each other without the pageantry of an official state visit.

Related

Read the complete report U.S. Policy Toward China: Recommendations for a New Administration Task Force on U.S.-China Policy.Learn more

This doesn’t mean these informal summits are merely of symbolic value. The visit of Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe to Mar-a-Lago in February — where he and President Trump enjoyed a round of golf and engaged in some slapdash crisis management — signified the enduring strength of the U.S-Japan alliance. Washington’s relationship with Beijing is decidedly more complex. But the fact that the Xi and Trump can come together for an amicable visit is meant to reassure observers concerned that Sino-American relations may become more volatile. “These casual, short-sleeved summits give each leader a gut-check about the other,” said Isaac Stone Fish, a senior fellow at the Center on U.S.-China Relations. “And that’s very important.”

There is a possibility that this summit may exceed its modest expectations for action. President Trump’s zeal for negotiation — combined with his stated desire to upend the existing order — may actually endear him to Xi and the Chinese, who have long chafed at what they perceive as the American preference for principle over pragmatism.

“[Trump] has a value-free version of how you interact with other leaders that the Chinese could find quite welcome,” Orville Schell, the Arthur Ross Director of the Center on U.S.-China Relations, told the Los Angeles Times.

What is the state of U.S.-China relations leading into the summit?

During his campaign for the presidency, Trump forcefully and repeatedly used strong rhetoric to describe his displeasure with China, whom he accused of manipulating its currency and “raping our country." As president, Trump vowed to label China a currency manipulator and re-negotiate the two countries’ trade relationship, which Trump believed had greatly disadvantaged the United States.

After his victory, Trump sparked a diplomatic imbroglio in December when he accepted a congratulatory phone call from Taiwan President Tsai Ing-wen. The conversation, which marked the first direct communication between a Taiwanese leader and American president or president-elect since the U.S. broke off formal relations with the island in 1979, infuriated Beijing.

In the months since, however, Trump has seemingly moderated his stance toward China. In February, he reassured Xi during a phone conversation that the U.S. still upheld the One China Policy. And during a visit to Beijing last month, Secretary of State Rex Tillerson struck a conciliatory note toward China.

What do Trump and Xi want to achieve from the summit?

Expecting tangible results from a gathering as informal as this week’s summit may be unrealistic. Nevertheless, it’s worth considering what Trump — and the U.S. — want to get from its relationship with China.

In February, the Task Force on U.S.-China Policy — a collection of experts convened by Asia Society’s Center on U.S.-China Relations and UC San Diego — issued six policy recommendations for President Trump on how to structure his administration’s China policy. These were:

  • Work with China to halt North Korea’s nuclear and missile program
  • Reaffirm U.S. commitments to Asia
  • Deploy effective tools to address the lack of reciprocity in U.S. trade and investment relations with China
  • Intensify efforts to encourage a principled, rules-based approach to the management and settlement of Asia-Pacific maritime disputes
  • Respond to Chinese civil society policies that harm U.S. organizations, companies, individuals, and the broader relationship
  • Sustain and broaden U.S.-China collaboration on global climate change

Considering his executive order last week curbing government enforcement of climate change regulations, President Trump’s commitment to collaborating with China to combat global climate change is dubious. But several of these other issues remain at play. Consider North Korea. President Kim Jong Un has accelerated the country’s nuclear weapons program, indicating as recently as last week that a subsequent nuclear test may be imminent. Neither China nor the United States wants this to happen. But that doesn’t mean that the two sides’ goals are aligned: Beijing is far less willing than Washington to apply pressure on Pyongyang for fear that the regime will collapse. Obtaining concessions from Xi on the North Korean question would be a victory for the president.

Then there’s trade. Trump’s frequent accusation that China was “stealing” jobs from the U.S. due to currency manipulation and unfair trade practices do not stand up to scrutiny: Most economists believe that China stopped weakening its currency several years ago, and Beijing has more recently even taken measures to prop up the renminbi. Short of achieving fundamental changes in the Sino-American economic relationship, Stone Fish said that Trump may look for a high-profile victory related to jobs — “to be able to say to his base, ‘I brought back jobs from China.’”

Xi is unlikely to make these or other concessions to Trump without something substantial in return. This might include a promise from the U.S. to pull back from the Pacific, where Washington has opposed Beijing’s efforts to construct artificial islands in the South China Sea. “A lot of what Xi wants is regional dominance,” said Stone Fish. “and I think that may be something Trump could compromise on.”

Is Trump ready for this?

In a December Asia Blog roundup of advice for the incoming president, Asia Society Executive Vice President Tom Nagorski suggested Trump appoint a chief envoy to manage the vital U.S.-China relationship.

“You should choose a high-profile, seasoned, globally savvy person to be your special representative for all things China,” Nagorski wrote. “It’s that important. You must have confidence in the individual, of course, but this should not be a ‘yes person’; you need to know you are getting unvarnished information and guidance.”

Less than 100 days into his presidency, Trump has not followed this advice. The Washington Post’s Josh Rogin reported that Jared Kushner, the president’s senior advisor and son-in-law, has established a communications channel between the two countries. The elevation of Kushner has not surprised anyone who knows Trump — the president has long relied on family members for advice. But Kushner’s selection has nonetheless raised eyebrows. Despite being personally introduced to key Chinese leaders through Henry Kissinger, the former secretary of state and chief architect of the U.S. decades-long policy toward China, Kushner has no known expertise or experience in the country.

In addition, China occupies only a fraction of his continually expanding portfolio. Trump has indicated that his son-in-law will be a point person in shaping the administration’s Israel/Palestine policy, and Kushner has already assumed leadership of a new White House initiative to streamline government functions. As if this wasn’t enough, the 36-year-old real estate developer reportedly traveled to Iraq this week with a top U.S. general.

Kushner’s assumption of a major role in U.S.-China relations coincides with the Trump administration’s slowness in filling out key roles in the State Department and elsewhere in the national security establishment. In 2013, by contrast, President Obama was a second-term president with a large foreign policy apparatus who already had extensive experience in dealing with China.

“This is a terrible time for Trump to have a summit with China,” said Stone Fish, “because he and his foreign policy apparatus are unprepared to really know how to deal with [the country].” 

Related Links

  • ChinaFile Conversation: What Should We Expect When Trump and Xi Meet in Florida…
  • Advice for President-Elect Trump From Around Asia
current affairs
politics
u.s.-china relations
advice
donald trump
xi jinping
isaac stone fish
center on u.s.-china relations
orville schell
washington post
los angeles times
tom nagorski
rex tillerson
tsai ing-wen
henry kissinger
barack obama
shinzo abe
kim jong-un
nuclear policy
environment
climate change
josh rogin
jared kushner

About the Author

Profile picture for user Matt Schiavenza

Matt Schiavenza is the Assistant Director of Content at Asia Society and Senior Editor of Asia Society Magazine. His work has appeared at The Atlantic, The Daily Beast, The New Republic, The Wire China, and strategy + business among other publications.

About
  • Mission & History
  • Our People
  • Become a Member
  • Career Opportunities
  • Corporate Involvement
visit us
  • Hong Kong
  • New York
  • Texas
global network
  • Australia
  • France
  • India
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Northern California
  • Philippines
  • Southern California
  • Switzerland
  • Washington, D.C.
resources
  • Arts
  • Asia Society Magazine
  • ChinaFile
  • Current Affairs
  • Education
  • For Kids
  • Policy
  • Video
shop
  • AsiaStore
initiatives
  • Arts & Museum Summit
  • Asia 21 Young Leaders
  • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
  • Asia Game Changer Awards
  • Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network
  • Asia Society Policy Institute
  • Asian Women Empowered
  • Center on U.S.-China Relations
  • Coal + Ice
  • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
  • Global Cities Education Network
  • Global Talent Initiatives
  • U.S.-Asia Entertainment Summit
  • U.S.-China Dialogue
  • U.S.-China Museum Summit
Connect
Email Signup For the media
Asia Society logo
©2023 Asia Society | Privacy Statement | Accessibility | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap | Contact

Asia Society takes no institutional position on policy issues and has no affiliation with any government.
The views expressed by Asia Society staff, fellows, experts, report authors, program speakers, board members, and other affiliates are solely their own. Learn more.

 

 

  • Visit Us
  • Hong Kong
  • New York
  • Texas
  • Global Network
  • Australia
  • France
  • India
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Northern California
  • Philippines
  • Southern California
  • Switzerland
  • Washington, DC