How Can Afghanistan Secure a Peaceful Future?
This lesson examines what happened in Afghanistan that led to the American-led war there. Students are challenged to think about what Afghans need to ensure a better future.
- Summarize key points clearly and succinctly in their own words.
- Consider alternate perspectives in an argument.
- Make an argument for ethical and responsible action in relation to its impact on the local communities and international stakeholders.
This lesson focuses on recent Afghan history, but does not cover events outside Afghanistan. High school students today have little, if any memory, of the September 11 attacks and the American-led response. They may have little understanding of what al Qaeda is. Depending on the prior knowledge of your students, you may need to provide a summary overview.
Two 50-minute class periods, plus optional extension exercise that may be completed outside class.
Quality of whole-class discussion Quality of response to an online article about Afghanistan’s future
Class period one:
Introduce the lesson by showing photos comparing women in Afghanistan’s capitol city of Kabul.
circa 2000s (PPT file)
Explain that in the last 100 years, Afghanistan enjoyed a long period of peace and stability as a sovereign nation before a Marxist overthrow of government and Soviet invasion in the late 1970s. The United States backed resistance fighters. After the Soviets withdrew, civil war continued, and finally, the American-led war ensued in 2001. This lesson looks at the 30 years plus years of war in Afghanistan, and challenges students to think about what Afghans need to ensure a better future.
- Split the class into four groups. Give each group an assignment sheet, “What Were the Roots of Conflict in Afghanistan?” Review the assignment with students.
- Assign each group watch one of the following videos and to follow the instructions on the assignment sheet. Set timer and give students 20 minutes to complete this task.
Group 1: Void After Victory
Group 2: The Rise of the Taliban
Group 3: A Fragile Nation Divided
Group 4: Wealth and Warlords
- After they watch the video, ask a representative from each group to summarize the main points of the video in one minute or less. You may want to play the video, without sound, in the background.
- As a large group discuss the fact that the Soviet Afghan War caused a rupture in the political, social, and cultural fabric of Afghanistan, and the effects of which have affected the world. How did the Soviet Afghan War create the conditions that led to the Taliban gaining control? How did those conditions also provide a safe haven for al Qaeda?
Class period two:
- Before class, print one set of Heiarchy of Needs cards. Print double-sided or tape paper together so that the front displays a basic human need, and the back has a short definition.
- Ask five volunteers to step to the front of the room. Give each student a card (shuffled).
- Tell the class that the objectives of the first activity are to deduce what human needs are most basic, and what needs are contingent upon others.
- Each of the five students will read the small-text description on the back of the card, while holding up the front of the card for the whole class to see.
- Through constructive debate, the class has to help order the cards from most basic needs to the higher order needs. In other words, what needs must be met before focusing on achieving the next level of needs?
The answer, from most basic to highest-order: physiological, safety, love/belonging, esteem, self-actualization.
- Write or project this on the board: “Our security as Americans depends on the security of Afghans.”
- Show these videos to the class:
A Song for Afghanistan
- Discuss: Does the class agree with the first statement, that American security is contingent on Afghan security? Why or why not?
Ask students to find an online article offering broad analysis of current Afghanistan strategies (they should not look for news coverage of a specific event). Students should offer comments in the comment field.
- State ideas clearly and succinctly
- Compels thinking of alternative perspectives or strategies.