Lessons in Equity | Asia Society Skip to main content

Unsupported Browser Detected.
It seems the web browser you're using doesn't support some of the features of this site. For the best experience, we recommend using a modern browser that supports the features of this website. We recommend Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Microsoft Edge

  • Professional Development
    • Global Ed Explorer
    • Online Courses
  • Educator Resources
    • Teaching for Global Understanding
  • About the Network
    • Meeting History & Agendas
    • Approach and Impact
    • Reports
  • About the Center for Global Education
    • Who We Are
    • Where We Work
    • Results and Opportunities
    • News and Events
Search
Global Cities Education Network
  • Professional Development
    • Global Ed Explorer
    • Online Courses
  • Educator Resources
    • Teaching for Global Understanding
  • About the Network
    • Meeting History & Agendas
    • Approach and Impact
    • Reports
  • About the Center for Global Education
    • Who We Are
    • Where We Work
    • Results and Opportunities
    • News and Events

Lessons in Equity

From the 2015 GCEN Summit

Students in a Hangzhou classroom (Heather Singmaster/Asia Society)

By Jal Mehta

In November of 2015, I attended Asia Society’s Global Cities Education Network (GCEN) annual summit in Shanghai. The summit brought together representatives from all of the GCEN members, including ministry officials from China, Singapore, Korea, and Japan, and district officials from the US cities of Houston, Lexington, Oakland, and Seattle, as well as from Toronto and Melbourne.

The purpose of the meeting was to examine Shanghai’s education system with an equity lens and to participate in working groups from across the cities to work on common issues such as 21st century skills and improving career and technical education. The summit was the fifth in a series of symposia hosted by GCEN.

Below, I’d like to share a few takeaways, with the admission that these insights are from a brief five-day window into an enormously complex set of issues:

1) Beyond Queen Bees and Wannabes

While the American participants had joined this network to learn how top-performing systems abroad worked, the Asian participants were equally eager to hear about aspects of the American approach, particularly with respect to developing creativity. Many of the Asian ministry officials had experience in the US higher education system, and had strong memories of powerful seminars or graduate classes they had taken in the US.

Coupled with the fact that they had strong examination systems and thus an emphasis on performing to external metrics, they were very curious about what education would look like that was more intrinsically motivated and more focused on helping students develop their interests and passions. All of the cities were part of a 21st century skills working group, suggesting that everyone is trying to figure out how to integrate the old and the new, how to help students master basic content while also pushing them to reason and create.

2) Systems Are Integrated Wholes; Beware Piecemeal "Lessons" That Ignore the System

One of the lessons that has been taken from abroad the past few years is the idea that teachers in other countries have more time to plan and collaborate, whereas US teachers are more frequently in front of students. Recent reconsideration of that evidence has suggested the gap was not as large as previously thought, but the gap still persists. The schools we visited suggest that Shanghai teachers do have remarkably large amounts of time to plan; at one high school teachers described teaching three 45-minute blocks a day, and having the rest of the day to plan and collaborate. But they do this through having very large class sizes—40-50 in the high school, and 40 or so in the elementary schools. We could do that too—rather than teaching 25 at 9:00 a.m. and 25 at 10 a.m., we could have teachers teach 50 at 9 a.m. and then plan from 10–11.

But in the Chinese system, having larger classes is seemingly not that problematic, because much of the teaching is fairly traditional frontal teaching (lecture, or I do/we do/you do); it would be much more difficult to run seminars, say, using this system. Mindful that these kinds of visits show you only the schools that people want you to see, at those schools we saw a very high level of attention from the students, which everyone (teachers, school administrators, ministry officials) we talked to attributed to a combination of Confucian culture, low to modest levels of poverty in our host schools, and, for high school students, the college entrance exams that govern the system. Thus in a system with frontal teaching and high levels of behavioral control, you can have larger classes, which creates more time for planning.

If we tried to import classes of 50 into the US system to create more planning time, without attending to questions of behavior, poverty, and more varied pedagogical methods, chances are it would not work too well. The lesson I take from this is not that you can't learn things from other countries, but rather that you have to think in terms of systemic wholes; plucking lessons and importing them into very different kinds of systems will require attention to how the parts fit into the whole.

3) Unlearning is a Challenge at the System Level, Too

I've written previously about the challenge of "unlearning" for teachers and schools—specifically the way in which some sets of existing commitments make it hard to take on new commitments. These visits suggest the same challenges exist at the national level. For example, as mentioned above, China was one of several East Asian countries that expressed considerable interest in education that gave students more room to follow their own passions and develop their own interests. But they expressed no interest in moving away from, or lessening the role of, their longstanding college examination system (which has roots in a several millennia-old civil examination system), which they saw as the key to having an objective and meritocratic school system.

Thus they were trapped between new goals they aspired to and old commitments they did not want to discard. This was quite parallel to what I've seen in some American "no excuses" schools—success in an examination-based system (featuring high levels of behavioral control and good test scores) getting in the way of a newer commitment to more student-driven learning, which might undermine the success of what they had already accomplished. The difference is that when whole nations have taken such an approach it is difficult to experiment and try new configurations without huge risks to what has already been accomplished, meaning that systems change is a quite conservative process. It also suggests, consistent with political scientists' work on path dependency, that it is likely that different nations will take different paths, consistent with their history and their values, even as they seek some similar goals.

On a more personal note, seeing how whole other systems were organized was really useful for reflecting on our own. There is much more variation across countries than within them in how they handle a given educational challenge (i.e., second language learning, special education, career and technical education, equity) and thus the increasing interest in global education has the potential to make all of us less parochial in how we think. For example, it was striking to be reminded that no other country has made anywhere near the investment in individual teacher evaluations that the United States has; perhaps everyone else is wrong and we are right, or perhaps the world consensus has it right and we are wrong. But an international perspective forces us to at least reflect on these big questions, which are largely invisible from within a given country's policy debates.

A version of this article was originally published on Education Week’s Learning Deeply blog.

 

You Might Also Like

  • Future of Teaching and Learning 2019
    report
     /  Education

    The Future of Teaching and Learning

    Read the report from the 2019 International Summit on the Teaching Profession, which focused on the future of teaching and learning.
  • Cover of the 2018 International Summit of the Teaching Profession report
    report
     /  Education

    New Challenges and Opportunities Facing the Teaching Profession in Public Education

    Read the report from the 2018 International Summit on the Teaching Profession, which focused on new challenges and opportunities for educators in public education.
  • Edinburgh with the ISTP 2017 logo
    report
     /  Education

    Empowering and Enabling Teachers to Improve Equity and Outcomes for All

    The 2017 International Summit on the Teaching Profession focused on sustainable excellence and equity in learning.
  • Students at a primary school in Japan. (Center for Global Education/Asia Society)

    Why Japan Must 'Change the Minds of a Million Teachers'

    Japanese education official Kan Suzuki discusses the challenges of preparing Japanese students for a rapidly changing world.
  • Andreas Schleicher speaks at Asia Society in New York on December 8, 2016. (Elsa Ruiz/Asia Society)

    PISA Results Show Need to Address Inequity in Education

    “The good news is inequality is diminishing. ... The bad news is the remaining inequality makes much more of a difference for people.”
  • Students in Guizhou, China. (Thomas Galvez/Flickr)

    The Challenges in Bringing Global Education to China

    Educational psychologist Kit-Tai Hau discusses how China can bridge the rural-urban education divide, and where global competence falls amid a tough political environment.
  • Singapore Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong (R) and school children look at digital interactive media during the opening of the newly restored National Gallery in Singapore on November 23, 2015. (Mohd Fyrol/AFP/Getty)

    How Singapore Readies its Students for a Globalized World

    Professor Lee Sing Kong discusses what his country is doing to develop "globally competent" students, and why a tide of nationalism cannot win.
  • 2016 International Summit on the Teaching Profession
    report
     /  Education

    Creating the Conditions to Achieve Quality Teaching for Excellent Learning Outcomes

    How can we create the conditions to achieve quality teaching for excellent and equitable learning outcomes? The 2016 International Summit on the Teaching Profession looked to answer this question.
  • Students at the school of the Shanghai Construction Group (Heather Singmaster)

    Chinese Innovations in Career and Technical Education

    Worldwide, there is a mismatch between the skills needed for open positions in the labor market and those of available workers. Vivien Stewart shares what the world's largest education system is doing to raise the quality of its workforce.
  • Students in class in Vietnam (Vanessa Shadoian-Gersing)

    Education in Vietnam

    Vietnamese students surprised the world with their 2012 PISA results. Vanessa Shadoian-Gersing, a former OECD analyst who writes and consults on global education, offers observations based on her recent work in Vietnam.

Pagination

  • Current page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Next page Next
  • Last page Last

  • Learning Across National Boundaries

    Amelia Peterson and Jal Mehta are investigating the learning experiences of participants in international learning communities, including Asia Society's Global Cities Education Network.

Related Video

  • Policy
     /  India

    Recalibrating Moral Paradigms: Lockdown Lessons for Inclusive Development

    A discussion on the need for reforms in India's social structures and ways to improve public welfare frameworks against the backdrop of the COVID-19 pandemic.
    Watch Now
  • Current Affairs
     /  India

    Beyond the Vaccine: Public Health System’s Revival in India

    Health experts discuss the present challenges facing India's public health system and ways to make delivery of quality health services equitable and accessible.
    Watch Now
  • Education
     /  New York

    A Global Approach to Education

    Watch: experts assess validity of the PISA scores worldwide.
    Watch Now
  • Education

    Mapping the Nation (Complete)

    U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan, Asia Society's Tony Jackson and other officials introduce the interactive project "Mapping the Nation."
    Watch Now
  • Education

    An Agenda of Equity and Excellence

    Australia's efforts to extend high academic performance to all students.
    Watch Now
About
  • Mission & History
  • Our People
  • Become a Member
  • Career Opportunities
  • Corporate Involvement
visit us
  • Hong Kong
  • New York
  • Texas
global network
  • Australia
  • France
  • India
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Northern California
  • Philippines
  • Southern California
  • Switzerland
  • Washington, D.C.
resources
  • Arts
  • Asia Society Magazine
  • ChinaFile
  • Current Affairs
  • Education
  • For Kids
  • Policy
  • Video
shop
  • AsiaStore
initiatives
  • Arts & Museum Summit
  • Asia 21 Young Leaders
  • Asia Arts Game Changer Awards
  • Asia Game Changer Awards
  • Asia Society Museum: The Asia Arts & Museum Network
  • Asia Society Policy Institute
  • Asian Women Empowered
  • Center on U.S.-China Relations
  • Coal + Ice
  • Creative Voices of Muslim Asia
  • Global Cities Education Network
  • Global Talent Initiatives
  • U.S.-Asia Entertainment Summit
  • U.S.-China Dialogue
  • U.S.-China Museum Summit
Connect
Email Signup For the media
Asia Society logo
©2023 Asia Society | Privacy Statement | Accessibility | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap | Contact

Asia Society takes no institutional position on policy issues and has no affiliation with any government.
The views expressed by Asia Society staff, fellows, experts, report authors, program speakers, board members, and other affiliates are solely their own. Learn more.

 

 

  • Visit Us
  • Hong Kong
  • New York
  • Texas
  • Global Network
  • Australia
  • France
  • India
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Northern California
  • Philippines
  • Southern California
  • Switzerland
  • Washington, DC