Immigration and Migration

Teaching About Tolerance, Diversity, and Trump's Travel Ban

Refugees in Europe (CAFOD Photo Library/Flickr)

Refugees in Europe (CAFOD Photo Library/Flickr)

Teaching About Tolerance, Diversity, and Trump's Travel Ban

NEW YORK, February 15, 2017 — The recent news has been dominated by President Trump's words, tweets, and actions, including one of his first, and arguably, most controversial: his executive order, "Protecting the Nation from Foreign Terrorist Entry into the United States," frequently referred to as a "travel ban" or "Muslim ban." Although the order is currently blocked from further implementation by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, fear and uncertainty remains, especially for students and families who are immigrants to the United States, and those who practice the Muslim faith.

Thus, it is ever more critical for educators to reinforce with all students that we are a diverse nation living in a global world, and we cannot function unless we respect other opinions and viewpoints with empathy and understanding. To that end, we have compiled a wealth of resources to help you facilitate discussions about diversity, inclusion, and current issues like the executive order with your students and your community. We will continue to compile resources on our website as we learn of them. As you come across valuable resources in your work, please share them with us, and we will add them to our collection.


Resources

Immigration, Migration, and President Trump's Executive Order on Travel

Below are the resources we found useful or interesting. If you find others, please share them with us, and we'll add them to this collection!

Is President Trump's Travel Ban a Good Example of Global Competence?
By Tony Jackson, Center for Global Education at Asia Society
If President Trump's travel ban were a piece of student work, would it be graded as globally competent? Asia Society Vice President of Education Tony Jackson shares his thoughts on this question by analyzing President Trump's travel ban through the lens of the four domains of global competence

How to Talk About Immigration With Your Students
By Laura Tavares, Facing History and Ourselves
Laura Tavares, with Facing History and Ourselves, on three ways to discuss immigration with your students.

'Learn from History!': Students Discuss the Muslim Ban
By Christina Torres, University Laboratory School in Honolulu
Christina Torres describes how she approached discussing the Muslim ban with her students. In her article, she writes: "We have two real jobs as teachers. Our jobs boil down to these things: First, to create a space of safety, validation, and ultimately love for our students; and second, to teach them how to critically question power, advocate for themselves and others, and resist oppression."

Against the Ban? Five Things You Can Do Now
By Joyce Dubensky, Tanenbaum Center for Interreligious Understanding
Tanenbaum's CEO Joyce Dubensky discusses the travel ban and provides resources for five ways you and your students can take action now.

President Trump's Executive Order on Immigration and Refugee Policy: Source Reliability and Analysis
By The Choices Program, Boston University
In this lesson plan from the Choice Program, students have the opportunity to practice source analysis skills; consider bias, audience, and author expertise to assess source reliability; learn about persuasive techniques and argument-building in media sources; and compare and contrast opinions about the executive order.

Trump's Immigration Ban: Ed School Weighs In
By Harvard University's Graduate School of Education
Perspective, reflections, and calls to action from members of the Harvard Graduate School of Education in the wake of the president's executive order on travel.

Immigration Protests Cast Spotlight on Social Studies Teachers, Content Developers
By Sydney Johnson and Tony Wan
The special role of teachers and content developers as nonpartisan guides in building civic engagement in students, particularly in light of President Trump's executive order.

In the News: Strikes and Boycotts
By the Morningside Center for Teaching Social Responsibility
In this lesson plan, students explore two forms of nonviolent protest, strikes and boycotts, using as case studies the strike by the New York Taxi Workers Alliance and the #DeleteUber campaign, both in response to an immigration ban imposed by President Trump.

"Extreme Vetting": U.S. Refugee Process and the Trump Ban
By the Morningside Center for Teaching Social Responsibility
In this lesson plan, students learn about and discuss the U.S.' existing policy for vetting refugees and what happened to refugees after President Trump signed an executive order temporarily suspending the U.S. refugee program.

All International Laws Trump's Muslim Ban is Breaking
By Jamil Dakwar
Jamil Dakwar is the director of the ACLU's Human Rights program, and in this opinion piece, he discusses President Trump's executive order in the context of international law.

Meet a School of Immigrants with a Complex Connection to Donald Trump
By Madeline Will
A famous California property that President Donald Trump once owned and fought to keep in a lengthy legal battle is now a multicultural K-12 campus of community schools that, in many ways, is antithetical to some of the president's pronouncements.

Great American Dreaming: Documenting Stories of Immigration in Your Community
By What Kids Can Do
One of the best ways to engage students in the critical debate around immigration, according to nonprofit organization What Kids Can Do, is to have them gather the stories (and images) of immigrants near at hand. Your students can bring back powerful interviews if they venture into their communities to talk to immigrants they meet or know about their experiences.

Uncomfortable Conversations: Tools to Teach Current Events and Controversial Issues
By Mackenzie Abernethy, Choices Program
How do you teach current events and controversial issues in an era of stark division and political and cultural divides? Mackenzie Abernethy, with the Choices Program, provides suggestions and resources.

I Was an Undocumented Student. Now I Teach Them.
By Ramiro Flores Turrubiates
Ramiro Flores Turrubiates teaches in the Rio Grande Valley in Texas and writes about his own experience as an undocumented student and those of his students.

What is the Process for People Trying to Become Refugees in the United States?
By the Choices Program, Boston University
The process for trying to become a refugee in the United States is long, complex, and difficult. The Choice Program breaks it down in this short video.

Asian Americans Then and Now
By the Center for Global Education at Asia Society
A look at the long history of Asian Americans, including Japanese internment during World War II, and its role in shaping American identity.

∨ Show resources


Diversity and Tolerance

Below are the resources we found useful or interesting. If you find others, please share them with us, and we'll add them to this collection!

Diversity is Our Strength
By Cleary Vaughan-Lee, Global Oneness Project
During this challenging time in history, when the political landscape is volatile and tensions are escalating, what if we imagined all of the children of the world as our own?

Classroom Resources for Teaching Tolerance
By the Southern Poverty Law Center
The Southern Poverty Law Center has compiled a wealth of resources for teaching tolerance from multiple and varied perspectives.

Structural Racism and Youth Development: Issues, Challenges, and Implications
By The Aspen Institute
This publication from The Aspen Institute describes the problem of structural racism, particularly as it relates to youth, and highlights implications for youth development work.

Seven Principles for Inclusive Education
By Tanenbaum Center for Interreligious Understanding
The well-researched and accessible pedagogy, Seven Principles for Inclusive Education, is the underpinning for all of Tanenbaum’s curricula and teacher training programs. The Seven Principles can be applied to any classroom or lesson plan to increase equity and decrease exclusion.

OECD Toolkit on Teaching for Diversity
By the Centre for Education Research and Innovation, OECD
How can teachers be equipped and supported to effectively teach increasingly diverse classrooms? The OECD Toolkit on Teaching for Diversity is designed to introduce useful concepts in teaching for diversity and to provide sample tools and activities for teachers to put into practice right away.

How to Help Diverse Students Find Common Ground
By Greater Good Science Center, University of California, Berkeley
Stanford University's Stephen Murphy-Shigematsu identifies eight principles that promote an inclusive learning environment that celebrates diversity and tolerance.

Building Empathy in Children: Lessons from Early Childhood Education
By Stefanie Paige Wieder
Stefanie Paige Wieder, a child development expert with over 20 years of experience working with families and educators, shares lessons and resources for building empathy in students.

Encouraging Respectful Conversation on Religious Diversity
By Maria Fasciano, Tanenbaum Center for Interreligious Understanding
How do we teach students to respectfully engage with peers of differing religious belief systems? Marisa Fasciano, education program associate at the Tanenbaum Center for Interreligious Understanding, shares ideas and resources.

Connecting Civil Rights and Global Competence for Powering Learning
By Homa S. Tavangar
Homa S. Tavangar, author of Growing Up Global and The Global Education Toolkit for Elementary Learners, explores how diversity education supports and aligns with global education.

∨ Show resources


Teaching About Islam

Below are the resources we found useful or interesting. If you find others, please share them with us, and we'll add them to this collection!

Debunking Stereotypes About Muslims and Islam
By Teaching Tolerance
Teaching Tolerance has developed a lesson plan for grades 6–12 to help educators discuss and debunk stereotypes about U.S. Muslims and Islam with their students. Students also have an opportunity to practice reading and interpreting charts and graphs.

The Five Pillars of Islam
By PBS Learning Media
In a lesson provided by PBS Learning Media, students explore and understand the basic beliefs of Islam as well as the Five Pillars that guide Muslims in their daily life: belief, worship, fasting, almsgiving, and pilgrimage.

The Backlash Against Teaching About Islam
By Kimberly Keiserman, Tanenbaum Center for Interreligious Understanding
Kimberly Keiserman, Education Program Associate, Tanenbaum Center for Interreligious Understanding, examines the backlash many educators are facing when teaching about Islam and provides resources on best practices for teaching about Islam and other world religions.

The Secret Life of Muslims
By Seftel Productions
The Secret Life of Muslims uses humor and empathy to subvert stereotypes and reveal the truth about American Muslims: fascinating careers, unexpected talents, and inspiring accomplishments, providing a counter-narrative to the rampant Islamophobia prevalent in the media.

Islamic Networks Group
Islamic Networks Group is a nonprofit organization whose mission is to counter prejudice and discrimination against American Muslims by teaching about their traditions and contributions in the context of America’s history and cultural diversity, while building relations between American Muslims and other groups. They offer curricula, speakers, and other educational resources.

Islam in Southeast Asia
By Michael Laffan
Michael Laffan writes about the history of the spread of Islam into Southeast Asia and how religion and expression fit within societal contexts.

∨ Show resources


Civics Education and Engagement

Below are the resources we found useful or interesting. If you find others, please share them with us, and we'll add them to this collection!

How Nonprofit Organizations Can Advocate with Confidence
By Shyaam Subramanian, Alliance for Justice
Shyaam Subramanian, Southern California Counsel, Alliance for Justice, shares ideas for how nonprofit organizations can use global competence to take action to solve both local and global issues.

Four Ideas for Approaching Political Conversations with Students
By Jessica Kehayes, Center for Global Education at Asia Society
These days, discussing current politics with young people can be like walking a tightrope. Jessica Kehayes, Executive Director, Center for Global Education at Asia Society, shares some ideas on how best to approach these conversations.

Teaching Global Competence Against a Wave of Anti-Globalism
By Ariel Tichnor-Wagner, ASCD
As the dust settles on the bitterly contested 2016 U.S. presidential election, many educators are seeing a clearer vision of what we must teach the next generation of voters.

Civics Education is the Foundation for Global Citizenship
By Heather Loewecke, Center for Global Education at Asia Society
Heather Loewecke examines how civics education can prepare all students to be active citizens of the United States and the world and provides resources for doing just that.

Learning Across Borders: Eight Lessons for Teaching Civics and Democracy
By Karen Murphy, Facing History and Ourselves
Educational curricula, systems, and approaches differ among cities, provinces, and countries around the world. Yet, educators struggle with some similar issues. In this article, Karen Murphy provides eight lessons for teaching civics and democracy.

Know Your Rights
By the American Civil Liberties Union
The ACLU has pulled together resources on your rights on multiple topics, including immigration, anti-Muslim discrimination, protests and demonstrations, and more!

United We Dream
United We Dream is the largest immigrant youth-led organization in the nation. They organize and advocate for the dignity and fair treatment of immigrant youth and families, regardless of immigration status, and they provide tools and tips for getting engaged and taking action.

iCivics
iCivics works to engage students in meaningful civic learning. Their mission is to ensure every student receives a high-quality civic education, and becomes engaged in the classroom and beyond.

Immigration, Xenophobia, and Racism: Teaching Global Competence Using the 2016 Presidential Election
By Apoorvaa Joshi, Center for Global Education at Asia Society
Asia Society’s Apoorvaa Joshi digs through the (mis)information in the 24-hour news cycle and provides ideas and strategies for using the 2016 presidential election to build students’ global competence. The lessons apply beyond the election and can be used broadly in civics education.

Neville Fights Back
By The Harry Potter Alliance
Sometimes, it can feel like problems are just too big—like we can't influence policy, or like hatred and bigotry are too powerful. At those times, we remember Neville Longbottom.

∨ Show resources


Personal Reflections, Opinions, and Stories

Below are the resources we found useful or interesting. If you find others, please share them with us, and we'll add them to this collection!

Reflecting on Character, Community, and Global Competence
By Apoorvaa Joshi, Center for Global Education at Asia Society
Apoorvaa Joshi came to United States at a young age and became a citizen as a teenager. In this piece, she reflects on her experience as an immigrant and the critical importance of global competence.

Why America Needs Foreign Entrepreneurs
By Ido Leffler, Yoobi CEO
Ido Leffler, co-chair of the Center for Global Education at Asia Society Council, reflects on his own journey to the United States and argues that immigration helps America's economy.

Where to Begin: Teaching in Times of Tumult
By Christina Torres, University Laboratory School of Honolulu
Christina Torres reflects on the challenge of discussing current events with her students during times of political and social upheaval and describes how she's been approaching such topics with her students.

The Antidote to Extremism
By Tony Jackson, Center for Global Education at Asia Society
Tony Jackson explores how global education can serve as an antidote to political and violent extremism of all stripes, and he examines the practices of two schools in Asia Society's International Studies Schools Network and how they're empowering their students to investigate the world, recognize perspectives, communicate ideas, and take action.

We Make America Great
YCTeen, Issue 255
The January/February 2017 issue of YCTeen focuses on student voices in the time of President Trump, with teens sharing powerful stories of their experiences and strong arguments for change.

Immigrant Issues
YCTeen
Students share their personal stories and their ideas on immigration in America, particularly in the time of President Trump.

Finding Perspective: Understanding the World Starts at Home
By Anne Hilton, Center for Global Education at Asia Society
Sometimes understanding the world starts at home. Anne Hilton reflects on the blind spot in her own journey toward global competence.

Keep Our Eyes Stayed on Freedom
By Tony Jackson, Center for Global Education at Asia Society
Asia Society Vice President of Education Tony Jackson on the critical imperative global educators face under a nationalist president.

Global Competence as a Matter of Equity
By Tony Jackson, Center for Global Education at Asia Society
Asia Society Vice President of Education Tony Jackson reflects on his own experiences with global competence and describes how teaching through a global lens can help address the equity issues we face in education.

Video: Asian Americans Offer Advice to President Trump
By Asia Society
In the 2016 U.S. presidential election, Asian American voters made their preferences clear: Exit polls suggested that despite Hillary Clinton's defeat to Donald Trump, Americans of Asian descent supported the former secretary of state by a 65 to 29 percent margin. In the aftermath of the election result, Asia Society gave Asian Americans a chance to give advice to the 45th president—on camera.

∨ Show resources